top of page

The Fear of Being Loved

Father Charbel Abernethy
Nov 7
6 min read

On the hidden wound beneath our striving for holiness


The Furnace: Three Reflections on the Healing of the Heart Part II



“Perhaps the deepest wound is not simply pride but the fear of being loved without having first become worthy of love.”


There is a poverty within the human heart that we will do almost anything to avoid seeing.


It is not merely the poverty of our sins or weaknesses. These, at least, can be named. We can confess them, struggle against them, and sometimes even take a certain satisfaction in the struggle. There is a more hidden poverty beneath them: the terrible suspicion that, as we are, we are not worthy of love.


Much of our life can be spent attempting to overcome this suspicion without ever recognizing it.


We strive to become good. We seek to become useful. We make ourselves necessary to others. We embrace difficult responsibilities, demanding disciplines, and sometimes forms of sacrifice that exceed our strength. We tell ourselves that we are seeking holiness, and perhaps we are. Yet beneath this sincere desire there may be another movement, almost imperceptible to us: the hope that, if we become sufficiently good, sufficiently faithful, sufficiently self-denying, we will finally be able to rest in the assurance that we are loved.


Even our longing for God can become entangled with this fear.


There is something almost unbearable about recognizing this.


For it means that what appeared to be our greatest generosity may have been mingled with an inability to receive. What we called courage may sometimes have been a refusal to acknowledge our limitations. What we understood as fidelity may have concealed a fear of disappointing others or of discovering that we were not the person we had imagined ourselves called to become.


None of this means that the good was false.


This is important.


The human heart is rarely governed by a single motive. Grace works within a nature that is wounded, confused, and divided. We may love God sincerely while also fearing Him. We may desire holiness while secretly despising our weakness. We may give ourselves generously while remaining unable to believe that we are loved apart from what we give.


The tragedy is not that our love was entirely false.


It is that we could not receive the love that might have made us free.


The Fathers understood that pride is not always what it first appears to be. It does not invariably take the form of obvious self-exaltation. Sometimes it appears as an almost desperate refusal to be poor. We cannot bear to be limited, dependent, unsuccessful, or ordinary. We cannot endure the thought that we might have nothing to offer God except the truth of our condition.


And so we labor to become someone.


Someone holy. Someone courageous. Someone indispensable. Someone whose sacrifices will finally justify his existence.


The religious life can give this striving a particularly convincing form.


For there are genuine sacrifices to be made. There is a cross to carry. There is a narrow way to follow. The Gospel does indeed call us to lose our lives.


But there is a profound difference between losing our lives because we know ourselves to be loved and attempting to lose our lives in order to become worthy of love.


Outwardly, the two may look remarkably similar.


Inwardly, they are separated by an abyss.


One is born of freedom.


The other may be sustained by fear.


And fear can masquerade as virtue for a very long time.


I find this difficult to write because I cannot pretend to stand outside what I am describing.


There are things in my own life that I can no longer explain as I once did. Choices that seemed courageous now appear more complicated. Forms of sacrifice that I believed necessary may also have been ways of refusing the truth about myself. I can see how often I moved toward what was most demanding, not necessarily because God had asked it of me, but because I believed that something greater must always be more difficult, more costly, more extraordinary.


Perhaps I did not know how to receive a life that was simply given.


Perhaps I believed that I had to justify it.


I do not know how much of this I understood at the time. I do not even know how much I understand now. There is a danger in looking backward and imagining that we have finally uncovered the secret explanation of our lives. The heart is too mysterious for such certainty.


Yet there are moments when something becomes painfully clear.


One begins to recognize how exhausting it has been to live under the silent demand to become worthy.


And one begins to wonder whether God was ever making that demand.


Consider the prodigal son.


He returns with a carefully prepared confession. He knows his unworthiness. He has rehearsed what he will say. He no longer expects to be received as a son. Perhaps he can become a servant. Perhaps he can make himself useful. Perhaps some diminished place in his father’s house can be earned.


But the father does not permit the relationship to be established on those terms.


He runs to meet him.


He embraces him before the son can repair anything.


The son must still acknowledge the truth of what he has done. Mercy does not make repentance unnecessary. But repentance is received within a love that has already moved toward him.


This is almost intolerable to the religious mind when it has become accustomed to measuring everything.


We want to know what must be done.


We want a rule, a discipline, a labor that will restore our standing.


We want to become worthy of the embrace.


And the Father embraces us in our rags.


Perhaps this is why genuine humility is so difficult. It requires something more frightening than admitting our faults. It requires relinquishing the belief that our worthiness is the foundation of God’s love.


We must consent to be loved while still poor.


Not after the poverty has disappeared.


Not after we have become the person we intended to be.


Now.


There is a kind of nakedness in this that no amount of religious accomplishment can prepare us to endure.


The elder who tells his disciple to remain in his cell is not merely teaching him to resist distraction. He is asking him to cease fleeing from the truth of his own heart. To stop searching for another place, another undertaking, another identity in which he might finally become acceptable to himself.


Remain.


Be poor.


Call upon the Lord.


Allow Him to find you where you actually are.


But even here we must be careful. We can turn poverty itself into another achievement. We can become proud of our humility, fascinated by our wounds, or secretly attached to the drama of our own dismantling.


The Fathers would have little patience for this.


They would direct us away from ourselves and toward Christ.


For the purpose of seeing our poverty is not to spend the remainder of our lives contemplating it.


It is to discover our need for mercy.


And mercy cannot be earned.


I think this is what makes the healing of this wound so slow.


We have learned through countless experiences that human love can be fragile, conditional, and withdrawn. We have learned to anticipate disappointment. We have learned to make ourselves agreeable, useful, strong, or admirable. We have learned to conceal whatever might make us difficult to love.


Eventually, these habits become so deeply rooted that we bring them into our relationship with God.


We imagine that He too must be persuaded.


We imagine that His patience must have limits resembling our own.


We imagine that He is waiting for us to become someone other than the person standing before Him.


And perhaps the most difficult act of faith is simply to believe that He is not.


I cannot say that this fear has been overcome in me.


I can recognize it more readily than before. I can see something of the suffering it has caused. I can see how it has shaped decisions, relationships, and even my understanding of vocation.


But recognition is not yet freedom.


There are habits of the heart that do not disappear because we have finally found words for them.


They must be healed.


And healing belongs to God.


Perhaps this is why prayer becomes simpler as the years pass.


There is less to explain. Less to defend. Less confidence in our own ability to change ourselves.


One begins to pray:


Lord, have mercy.


Lord, heal what I cannot heal.


Teach me to receive what I have spent my life trying to earn.


I do not know how to be poor without being ashamed of my poverty.


I do not know how to be loved without attempting to become worthy of love.


But You know.


And perhaps, for now, that must be enough.


The deepest wound may not be our failure to become holy.


It may be our refusal to believe that the Holy One has loved us all along.


And the beginning of healing may be no more dramatic than this: a weary man ceasing, for one moment, to make a case for his own existence, and allowing himself to stand before God without defense.


Not yet free of fear.


Not yet healed.


But no longer entirely unwilling to be loved.

2 Comments


Father Charbel Abernethy
Nov 07

The Furnace: Three Reflections on the Healing of the Heart

These three reflections emerged from my own struggle to look honestly upon my life and the ways in which even a sincere desire for holiness can become entangled with fear, woundedness, and the need to become worthy of love. I write not from a place of resolution or healing, but from within the struggle itself, hoping that something of my experience may speak to others.

Above all, these reflections are an invitation to discover, in the light of God’s mercy, that we need not become someone else to be loved, and that our wounds and failures need not have the final word.

Mercy does.

Like
srgertrude60
Nov 09
Replying to

Repent. Receive. Remain.

The good thief acknowledged his misery and knew there was nothing he could "do".

We are all, in some way, asked to this level of abandonment and trust. And it is in being humbled that allows one to truly understand the truth and the nothingness of 'self' and the abundant love and Mercy of God. The only thing we have to give God is our sins. Every thing else is gift. "Oh happy fault !" Remember this... my prayers are with you .

Thank you for allowing God's light to shine through you even in your misery. He is there.

Like
bottom of page