top of page

When Mercy Has the Final Word

Father Charbel Abernethy
Nov 7
8 min read

On gratitude, repentance, and the life we can no longer change


The Furnace: Three Reflections on the Healing of the Heart Part III



“The mercy of God does not wait at the end of our story. It has been present even in the chapters we can scarcely bear to read.”


There comes a time when we can no longer tell the story of our lives as we once did.


The events themselves have not changed. The years remain what they were. The choices have been made, the words spoken, the opportunities embraced or lost. There are relationships we cannot restore to what they once were, wounds we cannot undo, and paths from which there is no simple return.


Yet something begins to change in the way we see them.


What once appeared unquestionably noble may now seem mixed with fear. What we understood as fidelity may reveal elements of stubbornness. What we called courage may have been, at times, an inability to accept our own weakness. Even our most sincere sacrifices may have been entangled with the desire to become someone we could finally approve of.


Such recognition can be devastating.


It is one thing to repent of particular sins. It is another to begin questioning the understanding of oneself that gave coherence to an entire life.


We may discover that we have been living within a story that was never entirely true.


And yet it was our story.


We loved within it. We prayed within it. We suffered and hoped within it. We made promises, embraced responsibilities, and gave ourselves to others with whatever understanding we possessed.


We cannot simply discard those years because we now see them differently.


Nor can we return to them and live them again.


There is a particular sorrow in this.


The past does not yield itself to correction.


We cannot go back and become more humble at the moment when pride governed us. We cannot recover the years spent struggling against limitations we should perhaps have accepted. We cannot undo the damage caused by our blindness, however sincerely we believed ourselves to be acting.


We can ask forgiveness.


We can make amends where possible.


But we cannot make the past other than it was.


And perhaps this is where repentance begins to deepen beyond anything we previously understood.


For much of our lives, repentance may still contain an element of self-repair. We confess our sins, undertake a discipline, seek to correct our behavior, and hope to become better.


These are necessary things.


But there are moments when no act of self-repair can restore what has been lost.


We stand before the truth of our lives with empty hands.


The Fathers teach us that this is not necessarily a place of despair.


It may become the beginning of compunction: the sorrow of a heart that no longer wishes to conceal itself from God.


Yet there is a danger here as well.


We can become so absorbed in the examination of our wounds and failures that repentance gradually turns inward upon itself. We search endlessly for motives. We revisit decisions. We attempt to understand why we became the people we became.


We imagine that if we can finally explain everything, we will be free.


But the heart cannot heal itself through endless examination.


There is a point at which even the search for truth about ourselves must become prayer.


Otherwise, we remain imprisoned within the very self we are seeking to surrender.


The Desert Fathers did not teach their disciples to spend their lives constructing ever more elaborate accounts of their failures. They taught them to acknowledge their sins, humble themselves, and cry out to God.


The movement was always toward Him.


Not toward a perfected understanding of themselves.


This is something I am only beginning to understand.


I have spent much of my life trying to discern its meaning while still living it. I sought to understand the demands of vocation, the significance of suffering, the purpose of particular obediences, and the relationship between my desires and what I believed God was asking of me.


There was sincerity in this.


There was also, I now suspect, a great deal of fear.


I wanted to know that I was doing the right thing. I wanted to know that the sacrifices had meaning. I wanted to believe that the difficulties were leading somewhere and that perseverance would eventually reveal their purpose.


Perhaps I wanted a kind of certainty that the Christian life does not promise.


And now there are things I cannot explain.


I do not know why certain paths opened before me only to close. I do not know why I remained in some circumstances long after they had ceased to be life-giving. I do not know how much was obedience, how much was fear, how much was pride, and how much was simply the bewilderment of a man trying to be faithful with a wounded heart.


I cannot separate these things with confidence.


Nor do I wish to invent a providential explanation that makes everything appear necessary.


Some things were simply painful.


Some things were wrong.


Some things should not have happened.


Some things I should have done differently.


To acknowledge this is not to deny Providence. It is to refuse to make Providence an explanation that relieves us of the burden of truth.


God does not need us to call evil good in order to believe that His mercy is greater than evil.


And perhaps this is where gratitude begins.


Not in the conviction that everything happened as it should have.


Not in the belief that every wound was secretly a blessing.


But in the astonishing recognition that our wounds and failures were not the end of the story.


We are still here.


Still capable of repentance.


Still capable of prayer.


Still being sought by the mercy of God.


There is something deeply moving in the teaching of the modern elders concerning thanksgiving. Gratitude is not merely a pleasant disposition or an expression of religious optimism. It is a way of turning the heart toward God in the midst of its poverty.


Archimandrite Zacharou, following the spiritual inheritance of Saint Sophrony, speaks of the importance of thanksgiving in the life of repentance.


This does not mean that suffering ceases to hurt or that the soul must manufacture gratitude for what has wounded it.


Rather, thanksgiving becomes possible because the heart begins to recognize that God has not abandoned it.


Even now.


Even here.


Even after everything.


The discovery is not that we have lived well enough to deserve His faithfulness.


It is that His faithfulness has endured our unfaithfulness.


And this can become the beginning of a gratitude unlike anything we knew before.


In earlier years, we may have thanked God for the gifts we could recognize: opportunities, achievements, relationships, consolations, the apparent fruitfulness of our work.


Now gratitude may become much poorer and much more profound.


Thank You for not abandoning me when I did not understand myself.


Thank You for bearing with the pride I could not see.


Thank You for receiving prayers that were mixed with fear.


Thank You for the good that was real, even when my motives were not pure.


Thank You for those who loved me when I made myself difficult to love.


Thank You that my blindness did not exhaust Your patience.


Thank You that I am still permitted to begin.


This is not the thanksgiving of someone who has resolved the contradictions of his life.


It is the thanksgiving of someone who has begun to suspect that mercy was present even when he could not recognize it.


And perhaps this is why gratitude heals.


It does not erase memory.


It changes the place from which we remember.


We are no longer compelled to stand alone before the accumulated evidence of our inadequacy. We begin to remember in the presence of Another.


The past remains beyond our power to alter, but it is not beyond the reach of God’s mercy.


The wounds remain real, but they are no longer the whole truth.


The failures remain ours, but they need not become our final name.


The Fathers knew something of this freedom.


They could speak of themselves as sinners without despair because their attention was fixed upon the mercy of Christ. Their humility was not an achievement of psychological self-knowledge. It was born of standing before God and discovering that His compassion was immeasurably greater than their poverty.


This is why the remembrance of sin and the remembrance of God must never be separated.


Without the remembrance of God, the remembrance of sin can become unbearable.


Without repentance, gratitude can become superficial.


But when the two are held together, the heart may begin to soften.


It no longer needs to defend its entire history.


It no longer needs to prove that every sacrifice was wise or every decision faithful.


It can acknowledge what was good without denying what was wounded.


It can grieve what was lost without surrendering to bitterness.


It can give thanks without pretending to understand.


I do not know whether I have arrived at such gratitude.


There are still memories that trouble me, questions that remain unanswered, and losses whose meaning I cannot discern. There are moments when I look backward and feel sorrow rather than thanksgiving.


I do not want to conceal this beneath beautiful spiritual language.


Nor do I want to turn the possibility of gratitude into another demand placed upon a weary heart.


We cannot command ourselves to be grateful any more than we can command ourselves to be healed.


But perhaps we can ask for the grace to see.


And perhaps we can begin with the smallest things.


The prayer that still rises from the heart.


The face of someone entrusted to our care.


The quiet of a church in the evening.


The kindness of a friend who sees our poverty and does not turn away.


The simple fact that, after so much wandering, we still desire God.


These things do not explain the past.


They remind us that the past has not consumed everything.


There is still life.


There is still mercy.


There is still the possibility of beginning again, though beginning may look nothing like what we once imagined.


I find myself increasingly drawn to a prayer that asks for very little.


Not for the restoration of what has been lost.


Not for the vindication of choices I can no longer defend.


Not even for the assurance that I have finally understood the meaning of my life.


Only this:


Lord, have mercy upon what has been.


Have mercy upon what remains.


Teach me to receive this day without demanding that it justify all the days that came before it.


And if gratitude is possible, let it arise not from my ability to explain my life, but from the discovery that You have never ceased to love me.


Perhaps that is enough.


Perhaps it is more than enough.


There may come a day when we can look upon the whole of our lives without needing to turn away. Not because the wounds have disappeared or because every contradiction has been resolved, but because we have finally learned to see ourselves within the mercy of God.


I do not know when such a day comes.


I do not know whether it comes fully in this life.


For now, there is only the difficult work of remaining truthful, refusing despair, and allowing thanksgiving to emerge where it can.


The furnace has not necessarily grown cooler.


The questions have not all been answered.


The man who entered it has not yet become someone new.


But perhaps he is beginning to understand that he does not have to rescue his own life from its history.


He may entrust even that history to God.


And when words fail, when repentance itself seems beyond his strength, when he cannot yet give thanks for anything else, he may still whisper:


Glory to Thee, O God, that Thou hast not abandoned me.


Glory to Thee that my sins have not been the measure of Thy mercy.


Glory to Thee that even now I may begin again.


For our failures do not have the final word.


Our wounds do not have the final word.


Not even death has the final word.


Mercy does.

2 Comments


Father Charbel Abernethy
Nov 07

The Furnace: Three Reflections on the Healing of the Heart

These three reflections emerged from my own struggle to look honestly upon my life and the ways in which even a sincere desire for holiness can become entangled with fear, woundedness, and the need to become worthy of love. I write not from a place of resolution or healing, but from within the struggle itself, hoping that something of my experience may speak to others.

Above all, these reflections are an invitation to discover, in the light of God’s mercy, that we need not become someone else to be loved, and that our wounds and failures need not have the final word.

Mercy does.

Like
Sophia Bomba
Sophia Bomba
Nov 09
Replying to

It hit straight to the heart. Thank you Fr for sharing this.

"I do not know why I remained in some circumstances long after they had ceased to be life-giving."

When being crucified or when standing under the Cross, can it feel like it is "life-giving"

Like
bottom of page