The Furnace of Becoming Ordinary
On the dismantling of the religious self, the wounds beneath our striving, and the mercy of no longer knowing
The Furnace: Three Reflections on the Healing of the Heart Part I

“Unless a grain of wheat falls into the earth and dies, it remains alone; but if it dies, it bears much fruit.”
— John 12:24
There are moments when I understand why a man might wish simply to walk away from the life he has known. Not in anger, necessarily, nor even in despair, but from a weariness that reaches deeper than either. A desire to disappear into the hidden and ordinary warp and woof of daily existence. To cease being someone in particular. To live without the continual burden of explaining, defending, sustaining, or becoming something.
I do not know whether this desire arises from freedom or exhaustion. Perhaps both. I am increasingly reluctant to give a spiritual name to something I do not yet understand.
What I do know is that much of my life has been marked by a peculiar kind of striving. Looking back, I can see how often I moved deliberately toward things that were contrary to my temperament, my limitations, and perhaps even the natural inclinations of my heart. I was drawn toward what seemed greater, more demanding, more sacrificial. I placed myself in circumstances that required me to overcome weaknesses, fears, and deficiencies that I could scarcely acknowledge, much less understand.
There was something almost compulsive about it.
What I now recognize, at least in part, as a counterphobic movement was often understood by me as courage, obedience, or the willingness to embrace the Cross. I moved toward what frightened me, believing that the very difficulty of doing so might be evidence of God’s will.
Perhaps sometimes it was.
But I can no longer assume that it always was.
There is a difference between accepting the Cross and constructing one for ourselves. There is a difference between the ascetical struggle that purifies the heart and the relentless effort to overcome the person we actually are. There is a difference between surrendering ourselves to God and attempting, through religious striving, to fashion a self that we believe will finally be worthy of Him.
These distinctions are not easily made when one is young. They are perhaps even more difficult when one’s deepest desires are sincere.
I wanted God. Of that I have little doubt.
But I also wanted to become someone capable of giving everything to Him. And somewhere within that desire there may have been an unrecognized conviction that the person I already was could not possibly be enough.
It is painful to write those words.
For more than forty years, my life has unfolded within religious structures, communities, ministries, and expectations that gave shape to my understanding of fidelity. There were genuine gifts, moments of grace, friendships, sacrifices, and encounters with God that I would never wish to deny. Yet there were also wounds and disorders, some inherited across generations, others perpetuated through institutional habits that had long ceased to be questioned.
I remained in circumstances that were often profoundly at odds with the life I had entered religious life to seek.
I saw possibilities everywhere. Possibilities for renewal, for deeper prayer, for authentic community, for a more radical embrace of the Gospel. And because I could see what might be, I struggled for years against what actually was.
I swam upstream.
I believed that enough perseverance, enough creativity, enough sacrifice, perhaps even enough suffering, might bring something good into being.
But what if the foundations themselves were unsound?
What if the very vision of religious life being cultivated was too narrow, too dependent upon human achievement, institutional identity, academic distinction, material expansion, or the endless multiplication of projects and programs?
None of these things is necessarily evil. Learning can serve truth. Institutions can protect and transmit a living tradition. Buildings can shelter prayer. Ministries can become instruments of mercy.
But they can also become substitutes for the very life they are meant to serve.
A community can become enamored of its own possibilities. It can mistake activity for vitality, visibility for fruitfulness, and the preservation of its identity for fidelity to God.
And a man who already believes that holiness consists in overcoming himself may find such an environment almost perfectly suited to his wounds.
The institution asks him to become more.
His own interior demands tell him that he must.
And so he continues.
For years.
For decades.
Until the distinction between vocation and self-construction becomes almost impossible to discern.
I hesitate to call all of this pride, although pride was surely present. It would be too easy, and perhaps another form of violence against the truth, to reduce an entire life to a single passion. Human motives are rarely pure, even when the longing that animates them is genuine.
There was love in those years. There was generosity. There was a real desire to serve Christ and His Church.
But there was fear as well.
Fear of weakness. Fear of inadequacy. Fear of being ordinary. Fear, perhaps, that without some great sacrifice or demanding religious identity, my life would amount to very little.
And beneath these fears there may have been something still more deeply rooted: the inability to receive my own existence as a gift rather than a problem to be overcome.
This is where the dismantling becomes particularly painful.
It is one thing to relinquish a position, a ministry, a title, or an institutional belonging. It is another to discover that much of one’s understanding of holiness has been intertwined with the very identity that is now being stripped away.
The religious self can be extraordinarily resilient.
It can survive disappointment, humiliation, rejection, and failure. Indeed, it can incorporate these experiences into its own understanding of significance. It can make a story of its suffering, a virtue of its endurance, even a kind of distinction out of its wounds.
I recognize this possibility within myself, and it frightens me.
For even the dismantling of the religious self can become another religious project.
One can begin to take pride in having relinquished pride. One can become attached to being hidden, to being misunderstood, to having suffered, to having discovered what others have not.
The old self is capable of entering the desert with us.
It can even learn the language of the Desert Fathers.
Perhaps this is why the furnace must be so terrible.
Not because God delights in our suffering, nor because every painful circumstance is His direct doing, but because there are attachments so deeply woven into our understanding of ourselves that we scarcely recognize them until they begin to loosen.
And the loosening can feel like death.
I have spoken before of the furnace in which the heart is purified. It is easy enough to speak of such things in the language of the Fathers. We read of purification, detachment, the stripping away of self-will, and the passage through darkness into the light of God.
But the reality is not nearly so orderly.
There is no guarantee that we will recognize grace in the moment of our undoing. No assurance that the suffering will seem meaningful while it is being endured. No clear sequence by which one moves from the false self to the true, from confusion to understanding, from loss to peace.
There are days when what is being dismantled feels less like an illusion than like the very substance of one’s life.
And perhaps that is what makes it so frightening.
I do not know how much of what I once believed about myself was true. I do not know how much was shaped by fear, by the wounds of others, by the expectations of religious life, or by my own desire to become something greater than the person I was.
I cannot simply separate these things now, placing the good on one side and the disordered on the other.
They have grown together for too long.
The wheat and the tares are not easily distinguished within the human heart.
And I have come to fear the violence of attempting to tear them apart by my own judgment.
Perhaps this, too, is part of repentance: to relinquish the need to render a final verdict upon one’s life.
To acknowledge what was wounded without declaring everything worthless.
To recognize what was disordered without denying the grace that was present.
To confess pride without pretending that love was absent.
To grieve what has been lost without making grief itself into an identity.
And to resist the temptation to turn even these realizations into another account of spiritual progress.
I find myself increasingly drawn toward the ordinary.
Not toward an imagined life of uninterrupted silence, gentle prayer, and freedom from conflict. Such a life exists more readily in the imagination than in the world.
The ordinary life before me is demanding. It is marked by the frailty of someone I love, by the repetition of small necessities, by fatigue, uncertainty, interruptions, and the gradual narrowing of possibilities.
There are moments of tenderness, certainly. But there is also frustration, helplessness, and the painful awareness of my own limitations.
I do not wish to romanticize any of this.
Caregiving does not automatically make a man holy. Hiddenness does not guarantee humility. Solitude can become a refuge from love as readily as a place of encounter with God.
And the desire to disappear may arise as much from wounds that still need healing as from any genuine movement toward spiritual freedom.
I must allow that possibility to remain.
Yet something within me has grown deeply weary of the effort to make life into something more than it is.
I no longer wish to construct a narrative of significance around every sacrifice. I no longer wish to measure fidelity by the magnitude of what is undertaken or endured. I no longer wish to confuse the demands I place upon myself with the voice of God.
I would like to learn how to receive a day without needing to justify it.
To pray without wondering whether I am praying well.
To care for another without imagining that such care must become a lesson, a ministry, or a testimony.
To enter a church and stand quietly among the faithful, without needing to occupy a particular place or fulfill a particular role.
To be a beginner without making a virtue of being one.
But even as I write these things, I recognize how easily they can become another ideal to pursue, another image of myself to cultivate.
The man who once sought greatness through extraordinary sacrifice may now seek it through extraordinary simplicity.
The same striving can survive beneath a different appearance.
And so I cannot say that I have arrived at anything.
I have not.
I do not know what this dismantling will mean for the years that remain to me. I do not know what form my life will take, what will be asked of me, or what must yet be relinquished. I cannot say with confidence that the peace I sometimes experience is the beginning of something settled, or that the uncertainties before me will be resolved in the manner I hope.
Even the longing for a more hidden life must be surrendered to God rather than possessed as another certainty.
I am not standing at the end of a journey with the wisdom to explain it.
I am standing within something that is still happening.
And it is terrifyingly real.
There is a particular sorrow in recognizing that one may have spent much of one’s life struggling to become a person one was never called to be. Not because the desire for holiness was false, but because it became entangled with an inability to accept one’s own poverty.
The Fathers speak so often of the knowledge of one’s weakness. Yet I wonder how frequently we turn even this knowledge into something to be mastered.
We acknowledge our weakness in order to overcome it.
We confess our poverty in order to become spiritually rich.
We humble ourselves in the hope of becoming humble.
And all the while, the heart remains occupied with itself.
Perhaps the deepest wound is not simply pride but the fear of being loved without having first become worthy of love.
If that is so, then healing will require more than the correction of mistaken ideas. It will require a surrender that reaches into places where the will cannot easily follow.
It will require learning to remain before God without the familiar defenses of achievement, usefulness, endurance, or religious distinction.
I do not know how to do this.
I can write about it. I can recognize its necessity. I can see something of its truth in the lives of the saints.
But recognition is not yet freedom.
And words, however carefully chosen, cannot accomplish what they describe.
There is a danger in writing even this reflection. I know how readily suffering can be shaped into something beautiful on the page, how easily confusion can be given an appearance of coherence, how tempting it is to find a consoling conclusion to a story that remains unfinished.
I do not want to do that here.
I do not want to make the furnace beautiful.
Fire burns.
It exposes. It disorients. It leaves us uncertain of what will remain.
And when the fire concerns not merely our circumstances but our understanding of ourselves before God, there may be little to hold on to except the mercy we have spent our lives proclaiming to others.
Perhaps that is where I find myself.
Not in the possession of some newly discovered wisdom, but in the painful recognition that I have understood far less than I imagined.
I have spoken of surrender while continuing to strive.
I have preached trust while struggling to relinquish control.
I have taught the wisdom of the desert while carrying within myself an almost unrelenting demand to become someone.
I say this not to discredit those years or the words spoken during them. Truth does not become false because the one who speaks it has not yet learned to live it.
But neither can the one who speaks it remain untouched by the distance between his words and his heart.
That distance has become increasingly difficult to ignore.
Perhaps the dismantling of the religious self begins precisely there, when the discrepancy can no longer be explained away, and when one becomes unwilling to preserve an identity at the expense of the truth.
There is grief in this. More than I know how to express.
Grief for the years spent swimming against the current. Grief for the wounds I did not understand. Grief for the ways I may have mistaken compulsion for fidelity and self-overcoming for holiness. Grief for the good that might have been, and for the limits of communities and institutions to which I entrusted so much.
And grief, too, for the man who believed that he had to bear so much in order to be faithful.
I do not wish to despise him.
He was trying, however imperfectly, to love God.
Perhaps he deserves something other than another judgment.
Perhaps he needs mercy.
I have no desire now to replace the old story with a more impressive account of its dismantling. I do not want to emerge from these years with a new religious identity polished by suffering, a more compelling explanation of my vocation, or some grand understanding of what God has accomplished.
I would be grateful simply to become more truthful.
To cease resisting the poverty that is mine.
To stop confusing the loss of an imagined self with the loss of God.
To allow the good that was real to remain good, and the wounds that were real to be acknowledged without needing to make them serve some greater narrative.
And perhaps, in time, to discover whether there is a way of living that does not require such constant violence against the heart.
But I cannot presume even that.
The future remains hidden, and I am learning how little I can demand of it.
For now there is a house, a mother who needs care, prayers that are sometimes spoken with attention and sometimes scarcely spoken at all, a body that tires, memories that still trouble me, and a longing for God that has survived more than I understand.
There is also the Church, before whose mystery I stand with questions that are not yet resolved, and with a desire for belonging that I cannot manufacture by an act of will.
I cannot say what will become of these things.
I cannot even say with certainty what will become of me.
But perhaps I can begin to relinquish the conviction that I must know.
The furnace is not finished.
The wounds have not all healed.
The religious self has not quietly disappeared.
And I am not yet free of the temptation to turn what is happening into another story about myself.
All of this remains painfully unfinished.
Still, beneath the fear and sorrow, there is sometimes a small and almost imperceptible willingness to stop struggling against what is true.
Not resignation. Not a triumphant surrender. Certainly not the serenity that spiritual language can so easily suggest.
Only the faintest consent to stand before God as I am, without immediately attempting to become someone else.
I do not know whether that consent will endure.
But tonight it is what I have.
And perhaps the only prayer I can offer without presumption is the one that has accompanied me through so much of this life, though I am only now beginning to understand how desperately I need it.
Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on me, a sinner.
Not on the man I hoped to become.
Not on the religious self I spent so many years constructing.
Not on the person I imagine might emerge from the furnace.
On me.
As I am.
Lord, have mercy.
_edited.jpg)
Praying for you Fr. Charbel as you seek Gods mercy and trust in His love….all things are passing aren’t they?….God never changes.
You are a good priest, Fr. Charbel, and a good man, a just man. Do not be discouraged! I see transformation happening in your experience. Yes, you are going through the furnace of humiliation. That is a reason to be encouraged. I am reluctant to offer Scripture quotes for fear of sounding cavalier or trite and not respecting the depth of pain and suffering you are going through. Just know that you are loved, both by the Father who made you and by us who follow you. Thank you for your raw honesty, for your vulnerability, and for all that you've done. You have changed lives for the better. Give thanks for the good things in your life and what…
Your words are prophetic to me: ‘Set the trumpet to your lips for a vulture is over the house of the Lord’ ’ (Hosea 8:1). Thank you for having the courage to set the trumpet to your lips.
The Furnace: Three Reflections on the Healing of the Heart
These three reflections emerged from my own struggle to look honestly upon my life and the ways in which even a sincere desire for holiness can become entangled with fear, woundedness, and the need to become worthy of love. I write not from a place of resolution or healing, but from within the struggle itself, hoping that something of my experience may speak to others.
Above all, these reflections are an invitation to discover, in the light of God’s mercy, that we need not become someone else to be loved, and that our wounds and failures need not have the final word.
Mercy does.