top of page

When Obedience Can No Longer Mean Remaining

Father Charbel Abernethy
9 hours ago
9 min read

Conscience, humility, and the surrender of our understanding of fidelity



“Not my will, but Thine, be done.”

— Luke 22:42


The Heart at the Threshold — Reflection IV


There are moments in the spiritual life when the very things that have given shape and stability to our existence become the place of our deepest struggle. What once seemed clear becomes difficult to discern. The commitments through which we sought to offer ourselves to God, and which have sustained us through many years, no longer seem to answer every question arising within the heart. We find ourselves standing before something we never anticipated, something that cannot be resolved simply by appealing to the decisions we made long ago.


I have been thinking a great deal about obedience in recent months. Not obedience as an abstract virtue, but as something that has shaped nearly the whole of my adult life. I entered religious life as a young man, with all the sincerity and limitations of youth. I wanted to give myself to God. I wanted my life to be formed by prayer, sacrifice, community, and the wisdom of those who had gone before me. There was much that I did not understand about myself, much that I could not have anticipated about the years ahead. Yet the desire was genuine, and I remain grateful for the life that grew out of it.


There is a temptation, when we begin to see things differently after many years, to look back upon our earlier commitments as though they belonged to another person, someone whose understanding was incomplete and whose choices must now be corrected. But I do not believe this is how we should regard the work of grace. God was present in those beginnings. He was present in the limitations of our understanding, in the imperfect motives that accompanied our generosity, and in the countless circumstances through which we were gradually formed. The fact that our understanding changes does not mean that the love which first moved us was false.


And yet fidelity to that love may eventually require us to ask questions that we once believed had been settled forever.


This is where obedience becomes difficult.


We often imagine obedience primarily in terms of remaining faithful to what has been entrusted to us. We keep our promises. We persevere through disappointment. We resist the inclination to abandon our commitments whenever they become burdensome. There is profound wisdom in this. The Desert Fathers understood how easily the restless heart can persuade itself that holiness lies somewhere other than where God has placed it. Abba Moses and the other elders repeatedly direct us away from the desire to escape ourselves through a change of circumstances. We carry our passions with us wherever we go.


But there is another danger, perhaps less obvious. We can become so attached to our understanding of fidelity that we cease to ask whether we are still listening to God. What began as an offering of ourselves can gradually become something we feel compelled to preserve. We may find ourselves defending not only a commitment, but the identity that has grown around it, the history that gives it meaning, and the image of ourselves that we have come to inhabit.


Then even obedience can become entangled with self-love.


This is one of the most searching aspects of the spiritual teaching of St. Sophrony. In his correspondence with David Balfour, we encounter a man whose longing for God led him through difficult questions of conscience, ecclesial belonging, and spiritual obedience. What strikes me in these letters is not simply the seriousness with which St. Sophrony approaches such questions, but his refusal to allow spiritual conviction to become a refuge from repentance. The heart must be purified even in its most sincere desires. We can seek what is holy and still seek it in a manner shaped by our passions.


I find this deeply unsettling, but also liberating.


It means that I cannot simply point to the sincerity of my intentions as sufficient justification for what I believe I must do. Nor can I regard the suffering involved in a decision as proof that it is God’s will. We are capable of deceiving ourselves in remarkably subtle ways, especially when our desires concern things that are good. A longing for truth can become impatience. A desire for integrity can become self-justification. Even the willingness to sacrifice something precious can conceal a desire to see ourselves as courageous or faithful.


The Desert Fathers would have us examine these movements without mercy toward our illusions, but with great mercy toward our weakness.


Yet this examination must not become another way of avoiding the demands of conscience.


There are times when remaining where we are may appear to be the safest and most virtuous course, particularly when others have come to depend upon our stability. We may fear causing sorrow, being misunderstood, or appearing ungrateful for what we have received. We may fear that a change will cast a shadow over the years that preceded it. And beneath all of these concerns there may be a deeper fear: that without the familiar structures of our lives, we will no longer know who we are.


I have begun to recognize how much of my own understanding of obedience has been bound up with such things.


For many years, I knew how to describe my life. I knew the language of my commitments, the expectations associated with them, and the place I occupied within a larger community. Even when circumstances changed dramatically, those familiar descriptions remained. They offered a kind of continuity when much else had become uncertain.


But the spiritual life eventually brings us to places where familiar descriptions are no longer enough. We must stand before God without relying upon the story we have learned to tell about ourselves.


This does not mean despising that story. It means allowing God to be greater than it.


Perhaps the most difficult thing about obedience is that it asks us to relinquish not only our own will, but sometimes our certainty about what obedience itself requires. We would prefer a clear command, an unmistakable sign, or the assurance that those whom we love will understand. We would like to know that fidelity will be recognized as fidelity, that our decisions will be judged according to our intentions, and that the path ahead will not involve unnecessary suffering.


But Christ offers no such guarantees.


In Gethsemane, obedience is revealed not as the absence of anguish, but as the surrender of the heart within it. The Lord does not conceal the sorrow of His humanity. He brings it before the Father. His prayer is neither an assertion of independence nor a denial of the suffering before Him. It is the perfect offering of Himself in love.


We must be careful not to compare our own struggles too readily with His. Yet His prayer reveals the form that Christian obedience must take. We bring our desires, fears, and uncertainties before God, and we ask that they be purified by His will rather than simply confirmed by it.


I am discovering that this is much harder than making a decision.


A decision can give us the illusion that the struggle has ended. We have chosen a direction, and we begin to imagine that everything which follows must now serve to vindicate that choice. But genuine obedience leaves us vulnerable. It requires us to remain willing to be corrected, to receive counsel that may challenge us, and to accept that the timing and manner of what unfolds may not belong to us.


There is a particular poverty in this.


We cannot compel others to understand. We cannot arrange circumstances so that no one will suffer. We cannot demand that God reveal the whole path before asking us to take the next step. And we cannot make the peace we experience within ourselves into an authority before which every other consideration must yield.


Peace is a gift, but it must remain joined to humility.


I think this is why the counsel of the elders so often returns us to prayer, patience, and the refusal to judge. The heart that seeks God must become spacious enough to bear uncertainty without filling it immediately with explanations. It must be able to listen without surrendering conscience, and to remain steadfast without becoming rigid. It must learn to distinguish the voice of God from the urgency of its own desires.


And perhaps most difficult of all, it must allow others the freedom not to understand.


There are people who have accompanied us through many years and who may see our present struggles very differently. They may interpret our actions through the commitments we once shared, through their concern for our welfare, or through convictions that remain deeply precious to them. It would be unjust to imagine that their inability to see what we see necessarily arises from a lack of charity or spiritual understanding.


They too are seeking to be faithful.


To recognize this does not remove the difficulty of conscience. But it may preserve us from allowing that difficulty to become a source of bitterness. We can acknowledge the goodness of what has been given to us, even when we can no longer understand our future simply in terms of remaining within it. We can speak truthfully without turning our words into accusations. We can accept the sorrow of others without making their sorrow the measure of God’s will.


I do not write these things because I have learned to do them well.


I write because I see how easily the heart seeks refuge in certainty, especially when it is tired. There is a weariness that comes from years of trying to reconcile things that do not seem easily reconciled. There is a longing to arrive somewhere, to cease explaining oneself, to live without the constant interior effort of holding together what has gradually become divided.


Yet even this longing must be surrendered to God.


Otherwise, we may simply exchange one form of captivity for another.


What I desire now is not the vindication of a particular understanding of my life, nor the satisfaction of proving that a difficult decision was necessary. I desire the freedom to stand before Christ without pretense. To acknowledge the grace that has accompanied me, the sins that remain my own, and the limits of my understanding. To receive what He gives without demanding that it conform to the life I once imagined.


And to remain faithful to the concrete obligations of love that are already before me.


For obedience is never merely a question of where we belong or what we may become. It is revealed in the ordinary demands of the present moment: in the person who needs our attention, in the prayer we offer when we are exhausted, in the willingness to wait without resentment, and in the refusal to make our uncertainty an excuse for neglecting what has been entrusted to us.


Perhaps these hidden acts of fidelity tell us more about the condition of our hearts than the great decisions over which we spend so much time agonizing.


I have come to believe that obedience is not ultimately the preservation of a particular form of life. It is the offering of the whole person to God, again and again, as that life unfolds in ways we could never have foreseen.


Sometimes that offering will mean remaining.


Sometimes it may mean departing.


But neither remaining nor departing is holy simply because it is difficult, or because we believe ourselves sincere. What matters is whether we are becoming more capable of repentance, more willing to relinquish self-will, and more deeply rooted in the love of Christ.


I do not know all that lies ahead. There are questions that remain unanswered and things that must be entrusted to the discernment of others. I am learning not to regard this as an interruption of the spiritual life. It is part of the spiritual life itself.


For now, I can pray. I can care for those whom God has placed before me. I can remain grateful for the years that have formed me. I can resist the temptation to defend myself before every misunderstanding. And I can ask Christ to preserve my heart from the subtle pride that would turn even the desire for obedience into an assertion of my own will.


Perhaps this is where the deepest freedom begins.


Not in finally knowing where we are going, but in no longer needing to possess the path.


Not in being certain that we have understood God’s will perfectly, but in being willing to follow Him with the little light we have been given.


And not in ceasing to love what has been precious to us, but in discovering that all love must finally be surrendered into the hands of the One from whom it came.


A Prayer at the Threshold


Lord Jesus Christ,


You know how much of my life has been shaped by the desire to belong to You. You know the sincerity of my beginnings, the failures of the years that followed, and the attachments that have grown even around the things I offered in love.


Do not allow me to confuse my own desires with Your will, or my fear of change with fidelity. Preserve me from the pride that seeks to justify itself, and from the cowardice that hides beneath the appearance of obedience.


Teach me to listen without fear, to wait without resentment, and to act without demanding that others understand.


Let me never despise what You have given, nor cling to it so tightly that I can no longer receive what You ask.


And when I cannot see the path before me, grant me the humility to remain where Your mercy finds me, offering You the little that I am.


For I do not wish to possess my life any longer.


I wish only to belong to You.


Amen.


⸻


Spiritual reference: St. Sophrony of Essex, Striving for Knowledge of God: Correspondence with David Balfour; the Desert Fathers, particularly the teachings on discernment, stability, and self-will in the Apophthegmata Patrum; Luke 22:39–46.

1 Comment


Joan Chakonas
Joan Chakonas
7 hours ago

Don’t worry. When the moment for decisive action takes place, if it even comes, the holy spirit will save you. Baptism is everything.

Edited
Like
bottom of page