To Love Without Being Understood
St. Silouan and the difficult freedom of loving without defending ourselves

“The soul cannot have peace if it does not pray for its enemies.”
— St. Silouan the Athonite
The Heart at the Threshold — Reflection III
There is something within us that longs not only to be loved, but to be understood. We want others to recognize the sincerity of our intentions, the struggles that have shaped our decisions, and the hidden suffering that has accompanied us along the way. When those closest to us cannot understand, the wound can be especially deep. We may discover within ourselves a sorrow that gradually gives way to resentment, or a desire to explain ourselves that becomes almost impossible to silence.
The Desert Fathers understood how easily the heart can become captive to such things. They knew that even when our suffering is genuine, even when we have acted according to conscience, the passions can take hold of what is true and make it serve our self-love. We begin to rehearse conversations, defend our motives inwardly, and imagine what we might say that would finally persuade another person to see what we see.
We may spend hours speaking to someone who is not even present.
And all the while, we tell ourselves that we are seeking peace.
I recognize something of this struggle in myself, particularly during this season of my life. There are questions that remain unanswered, hopes that I must hold lightly, and aspects of the future that I can neither anticipate nor arrange. After so many years of religious life and priesthood, I find myself increasingly aware of how much of my understanding of myself has been shaped by the responsibilities I have carried, the communities to which I have belonged, and the expectations that have accompanied them.
None of these things is insignificant. Much of what has formed me has been a gift, and I remain grateful for it. Yet I am discovering that even our gratitude for what is good can conceal an attachment to the place it has given us in the world.
We may sincerely desire to belong entirely to Christ while still wanting to know what such belonging will look like.
We may speak of surrender while quietly insisting that the future preserve something recognizable of the past.
And we may imagine that we have entrusted ourselves to God while continuing to seek reassurance that our lives will unfold according to the hopes we have cherished.
There is no virtue in pretending that these contradictions do not exist.
Indeed, the Fathers would have us look upon them without evasion.
St. Silouan’s teaching on love for enemies is among the most searching expressions of the Gospel because it reaches beyond outward conduct into the secret dispositions of the heart. He does not permit us to measure our love simply by the absence of anger or by our willingness to behave kindly. The heart must become capable of bearing another person before God, even when that person has wounded us, misunderstood us, or opposed something we hold dear.
Such love is not sentimentality. It does not require us to deny the truth, excuse what is harmful, or surrender conscience. It requires us to relinquish something more deeply rooted: the desire to make our own righteousness the measure of another person.
And here the struggle becomes painfully personal.
There are people and communities whose kindness has sustained me through many years. There have also been disappointments, misunderstandings, and experiences that have left their mark. I cannot speak truthfully about my life without acknowledging both. Yet I have come to recognize how easily the memory of suffering can begin to govern the way we remember everything else.
A wounded heart can become a merciless historian.
It remembers what confirms its sorrow. It gathers evidence for its grievances. It begins to interpret the past through the pain of the present until even genuine kindness seems overshadowed by what was lacking.
I know this danger because I have seen something of it in myself.
And I have come to understand that the question is not simply whether I can speak truthfully about the past, but whether I can remember it with a heart that remains open to mercy.
This is difficult because our wounds often become entangled with our identity. We begin to understand ourselves through what has happened to us. The more deeply we have suffered, the more urgently we may feel the need for others to acknowledge that suffering. We want our history to be recognized, our intentions vindicated, and our decisions understood.
Yet there is a hidden bondage in this desire.
The one who must be understood before he can find peace has placed his peace in the hands of another.
St. Sophrony, in his correspondence with David Balfour, repeatedly directs attention toward the purification of the will, humility, and the necessity of discernment in the spiritual life. His counsel challenges us to examine not only what we desire, but the spirit in which we desire it. Even a longing for something holy can become entangled with self-will. We may seek God sincerely and yet remain attached to the image we have formed of ourselves as those who seek Him.
This is a particularly searching thought for someone who has spent much of his life in religious formation and ministry.
The religious self can be remarkably difficult to relinquish. It is strengthened not only by vanity or ambition, but by years of genuine sacrifice. We have given ourselves to something we believe is sacred. We have endured hardships, accepted responsibilities, and shaped our lives around what we understood to be God’s will.
And because so much of this has been good, we may scarcely recognize the moment when gratitude for our vocation becomes attachment to the identity it has given us.
I find myself asking whether I am prepared to stand before God without the assurances that have accompanied me for so many years.
Can I allow the future to remain unknown without continually seeking to give it a shape? Can I accept that the Lord may lead me into a deeper simplicity than I had imagined? Can I remain faithful to what has become clear in conscience without demanding that others understand it as I do?
And perhaps the most difficult question of all: can I relinquish the need to see myself as someone who has relinquished everything?
I do not yet know how freely I can answer these questions.
I know only that they have become part of my prayer.
There is something severe about the honesty of the Desert Fathers. They do not allow us to take refuge in the appearance of virtue. They ask us to examine what happens within the heart when our desires are frustrated, when our judgments are questioned, or when the recognition we have hoped for is withheld.
It is possible to speak beautifully about humility while remaining deeply wounded by the smallest slight. It is possible to teach detachment while inwardly clinging to the future we believe we deserve. It is possible to speak of love for enemies while finding it difficult to bear the misunderstanding of a friend.
The Fathers do not expose these contradictions to humiliate us. They reveal them because Christ desires to heal the whole person.
Nothing within us is beneath His concern.
I have often spoken of this in our gatherings through Philokalia Ministries. We do not come to the spiritual life in order to construct a more admirable religious identity. We come because we are sick and in need of healing. We come because the heart is divided, because self-love has penetrated even our noblest desires, and because we cannot free ourselves by our own efforts.
But it is one thing to teach this and another to discover how deeply it applies to oneself.
There are moments when I look back upon the years and recognize how much of my life has been spent trying to be faithful to what I believed God was asking of me. I do not regret that desire. Yet I also recognize how readily the heart can become preoccupied with the meaning of its own fidelity. We want our sacrifices to have mattered. We want our struggles to have led somewhere. We want the years to form a coherent story that we can understand and perhaps offer to others as evidence of God’s providence.
But the Lord has not promised that we will understand the story of our lives.
He has called us to follow Him.
And sometimes following Him means consenting to the poverty of not knowing what our lives will become.
This poverty is not merely an idea for me. It has entered the ordinary circumstances of my days. Responsibilities have narrowed the space in which I once imagined my life unfolding. There are things I cannot undertake, places I cannot go, and plans that must remain unfinished. Much of what once seemed essential has become less immediate than the simple demands of love.
I wish I could say that I have received this narrowing of life without resistance.
There are days when I am tired, when my mind is occupied with questions that have no immediate answer, and when I find myself longing for a freedom that the present moment does not offer. At such times I discover how easily even a sincere desire for prayer, silence, or a more explicitly monastic life can become a subtle refusal of the obedience immediately before me.
This is not to diminish the longing for solitude or the ascetical life. Such longings have shaped me deeply, and I believe they remain important. But the Fathers remind us that we cannot use the desire for a holier life to excuse ourselves from the love required of us now.
The desert is not always where we imagine it to be.
Sometimes it is the room in which we have been asked to remain.
Sometimes it is the interruption that exposes our impatience, the responsibility that reveals our self-concern, or the silence in which we discover how much we still desire to control the future.
And sometimes the most searching ascetic struggle is simply to receive another person without inwardly demanding that he become different.
I have come to see how difficult this can be. We may outwardly refrain from judgment while inwardly continuing to argue our case. We may behave with kindness while secretly rehearsing another person’s faults. We may pray for someone and still desire that he eventually recognize how deeply he has misunderstood us.
Even our prayers can become entangled with the hope of vindication.
St. Silouan calls us beyond this. His love for enemies was not a technique for managing difficult relationships, nor a way of attaining inward tranquility while remaining untouched by another’s suffering. It was born of repentance and of a heart that had learned something of the mercy of Christ.
We do not know the hidden struggles of those around us. We do not know the burdens they carry, the fears that shape their judgments, or the ways in which they themselves are seeking to remain faithful to God.
The person who misunderstands us may possess virtues that put our own to shame.
The one whose judgment wounds us may be struggling to love us in the only way he presently knows.
This does not make every judgment correct or every action harmless. But it should make us hesitant to presume that we know the whole truth of another person’s heart.
I find this especially necessary now.
There are relationships I cherish and wish to preserve with tenderness. There are differences that cannot always be resolved by explanation, and questions that may remain unanswered for a long time. I want to speak truthfully when truth is required, but I am learning that no explanation can guarantee understanding.
Nor should my peace depend upon obtaining it.
How much time can be lost in conversations that take place only within the mind. We imagine objections, compose responses, anticipate misunderstandings, and defend ourselves against judgments that may never be spoken.
Meanwhile, the heart becomes exhausted by a struggle that has not actually occurred.
The Jesus Prayer calls us back from this imagined world into the presence of Christ.
Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on me, a sinner.
There is no defense in these words. No explanation of our motives. No attempt to establish our innocence.
Only the truth of our need.
And perhaps this is why the prayer has become such a refuge for me. It allows me to stand before God without needing to arrange the circumstances of my life into a coherent account. I do not have to explain what has happened or what I hope will happen. I do not have to persuade Him that my intentions are sincere.
He already knows.
And He knows what remains hidden from me.
My dear friends, I share these things with you not because I believe I have arrived at some deeper understanding of the spiritual life. If anything, this season has made me more conscious of how much I have yet to learn.
For years we have gathered around the words of the Fathers, speaking about repentance, humility, watchfulness, and the struggle against the passions. We have listened together to St. Isaac the Syrian, St. Silouan, St. Sophrony, and the great elders who remind us that the Christian life is not the acquisition of spiritual knowledge but the healing and transformation of the heart.
Now I find myself being examined by the very words I have so often spoken.
And perhaps this is as it should be.
The one who speaks and the one who listens are equally in need of mercy. We are companions in the same struggle, each discovering in different circumstances how deeply the heart resists surrender.
Some of you know what it is to lose a friendship, a vocation, or a community that once gave meaning and coherence to your life. Some have experienced the sorrow of being misunderstood by those closest to you. Others carry responsibilities that have quietly displaced the future you once imagined.
There are losses that cannot be explained away. There are wounds that remain tender for years. And there are times when fidelity to Christ requires us to continue walking without knowing where the path will lead.
I do not wish to tell you what these experiences mean in your life. I would rather stand beside you in the poverty they reveal.
Perhaps we can learn together to bring before Christ not only our suffering, but also the ways in which suffering has shaped our hearts. The resentments we have cherished. The explanations we have rehearsed. The identities we have struggled to preserve. The quiet conviction that, because we have suffered, we are entitled to be understood.
These things do not disappear simply because we recognize them.
We must return with them to Christ again and again.
And we must allow Him to teach us how to love.
As I write this, I am increasingly aware of how much of life must simply be entrusted to God. There are hopes that remain dear to me, questions whose answers I cannot hasten, and a longing for a deeper communion with Christ that has only grown stronger with the passing years.
Yet I am beginning to understand that even this longing must be purified. I cannot make my desire for God into a demand that He reveal the future. I cannot measure His faithfulness by the speed with which uncertainties are resolved. Nor can I presume that because a desire has endured for many years, I fully understand what He intends to do with it.
Perhaps the deepest surrender is not the relinquishment of desire, but the willingness to let God teach us what our desire truly means.
Tonight, there is no resolution to offer.
There is only the familiar quiet of the evening, the responsibilities that will accompany tomorrow, and the prayer that returns whenever my thoughts begin to wander toward things I cannot control.
I think sometimes of the young man who entered religious life nearly forty years ago, full of hope and longing, wanting to give himself entirely to Christ. He could not have imagined the years that would follow, the friendships and sorrows, the unexpected responsibilities, or the ways in which his understanding of fidelity would be tested and changed.
I feel tenderness for that young man now.
He did not know where the years would lead him.
He gave what he knew how to give.
And the Lord received it.
I pray that the same mercy will receive what remains of my life.
There is much I would still like to understand. There are things I wish I had done differently, words I wish I had never spoken, and moments when I failed to recognize the love being offered to me. I have sometimes mistaken my own certainty for faithfulness and my desire to be understood for a desire for truth.
I do not wish to spend the years that remain defending the story of my life.
I would rather learn to love.
To remember with gratitude. To acknowledge what has been painful without allowing it to govern my heart. To speak truthfully without seeking victory. To remain faithful to conscience without condemning those who see things differently.
And above all, to stand before Christ without needing to become someone in my own eyes.
Perhaps this is the freedom St. Silouan places before us: not that we will cease to suffer misunderstanding, but that misunderstanding need no longer determine the measure of our love.
I have spent many years speaking about the mercy of Christ. I hope that, in the years that remain, I may learn something more of how to receive it and give it.
For now, there is the quiet prayer of the heart, the person immediately before me, and the mercy of another day.
Perhaps that is enough.
⸻
A Prayer at the Threshold
Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on me, a sinner.
You know the years that have brought me here, the love that has sustained me, and the wounds that remain.
Forgive me for the judgments I have made, for the resentments I have cherished, and for the times I have desired to be understood more than I have desired to understand.
Do not allow my longing for You to become another form of self-love.
Remember those who have formed me, those who have borne with my weaknesses, and those whom I have failed to love as I should.
Teach me to receive this day without demanding to know what tomorrow will bring.
Give me tenderness toward those who cannot understand me, patience in the responsibilities entrusted to me, and the humility to remain before You without defending myself.
When I begin to seek refuge in the life I imagine, bring me back to the love You ask of me now.
And when I am tempted to measure my life by what I have accomplished, remind me that I have nothing to offer You that I have not first received.
I have so little to give You, Lord.
Receive even this.
Amen.
⸻
Spiritual reference: St. Silouan the Athonite, as presented by Archimandrite Sophrony in Saint Silouan the Athonite, particularly his teachings on love for enemies, humility, repentance, and prayer for the whole world; Archimandrite Sophrony, Striving for Knowledge of God: Correspondence with David Balfour, on spiritual discernment, self-will, and the purification of the heart.


_edited.jpg)



Comments