top of page

The Mercy of Simply

Father Charbel Abernethy
Nov 5
8 min read

A dialogue between an elder and his disciple



“After so much wandering, there would be an enormous mercy in the word simply.”


The disciple came to the elder late in the afternoon.


For some time he said nothing.


Then:


“Father, everything is well, and yet I am tired.”


The elder looked at him.


“What is tiring you?”


“I have lived between worlds for so long that I no longer know what it would feel like not to.”


“What worlds?”


The disciple hesitated.


“The Church that formed me and the Church whose mind has become my own. The priest I have been for more than thirty years and the man I might be if all of that were taken away. The monastery I have longed for and the house where obedience has actually placed me. Public ministry and hiddenness. What I was certain my life would be and what God has permitted it to become.”


The elder listened.


“I have spent years trying to understand how these things fit together.”


“Have you succeeded?”


“No.”


“Good.”


The disciple laughed.


“I knew you would say that.”


“Then perhaps you have been here too often.”


⸻


After a silence, the disciple said:


“I do not regret my life, Father.”


“I know.”


“I received everything through it. Scripture. The sacraments. Priesthood. The altar. The privilege of standing beside people in sickness and death. I have heard confessions. I have buried the dead. I have watched people suffer and watched grace hold them when nothing else could. I cannot call any of that false.”


“Then do not.”


“But something changed.”


“What?”


“I did.”


The elder waited.


“The Fathers changed the way I see. Or perhaps they uncovered something that had been there from the beginning. Saint Isaac. The desert. The Jesus Prayer. The long attention to the heart. Repentance not as an episode but as a way of seeing everything. I thought I was learning another part of Christianity.”


“And?”


“Eventually I realized I was learning how to breathe.”


The elder nodded.


“And now?”


“Now I sometimes feel that I have learned to breathe in a language that is not spoken in the house where I live.”


The elder was quiet.


“That sounds ungrateful when I say it.”


“No. It sounds painful.”


⸻


The disciple looked down at his hands.


“I have tried to solve it.”


“That was your first mistake.”


“I have written letters. Asked permissions. Waited for answers. Considered monasteries, different paths, different ways of belonging. I have imagined one future and then another. Each time I thought: perhaps this will finally give my life a shape.”


“And did it?”


“No.”


“What did it give you?”


“More waiting.”


The elder smiled gently.


“And what has the waiting given you?”


The disciple did not answer immediately.


“My mother.”


“Yes.”


“My room.”


“Yes.”


“My prayer rope.”


“Yes.”


“People who still come to me with their sorrows.”


“Yes.”


“The Fathers.”


“Yes.”


“Christ.”


The elder said nothing.


The disciple sighed.


“I know what you are doing.”


“What am I doing?”


“You are showing me that the life I keep waiting to begin has already begun.”


“Has it?”


“I think so.”


“Then perhaps the waiting is not empty.”


⸻


The disciple looked toward the icon.


“Still, Father, there are days when I feel like a priest with no home.”


The elder did not correct him.


“I know Christ is my home. I know that now more deeply than I knew it when everything around me seemed secure.”


“Then something has been given to you.”


“Yes. But I am still a man.”


“Unfortunately.”


The disciple smiled.


“I still want somewhere to belong.”


“Of course.”


“I want to enter a church and not feel that I am visiting someone else’s house.”


The elder looked at him more closely.


The disciple continued:


“I want to stand among people for whom the things that have come to shape my heart require no explanation. I do not want to explain why Saint Isaac matters to me. I do not want to explain the Jesus Prayer. I do not want to translate the desert into another language before I am allowed to speak of it.”


His voice became quieter.


“I want to breathe the same air.”


“Yes,” said the elder.


“That is all.”


“No. That is not all.”


The disciple looked up.


“You want communion.”


The word landed heavily.


“Yes.”


⸻


After a while the disciple said:


“Sometimes I rebuke myself for wanting it.”


“Why?”


“Because Christ should be enough.”


The elder shook his head.


“Do not use Christ against the desires Christ Himself has placed in you.”


The disciple waited.


“Christ is enough. But the Christ who is enough gave you water and oil, bread and wine, an altar, a people, a bishop, brothers and sisters. He gave you a Body. Wanting His Body is not a failure to want Him.”


“Even when the Body seems divided?”


“Especially then the wound is felt.”


The disciple’s eyes lowered.


“I sometimes wonder whether the mystery of Christ’s Body is greater than the divisions we experience.”


“Greater, yes,” said the elder. “But do not confuse what transcends our understanding with what can exist apart from the Church.”


“Then the visible Church matters?”


“Of course.”


“I do not understand.”


“The soul is more than the body. Try living without your body.”


The disciple smiled faintly.


“The mystery of the Church is greater than our ability to comprehend it,” the elder said, “but it is not an invisible refuge from the demands of communion. Christ did not give us an idea of His Body. He gave us His Body. A life to enter. A faith to receive. A people with whom to stand before God.”


The disciple was quiet.


“Then what am I to do with the pain of standing between worlds?”


“Do not make another wound.”


⸻


They sat quietly.


Then the disciple said:


“What troubles me is that I no longer know what I want to become.”


“Perhaps that is because you are finally asking the right question.”


“What is the right question?”


“Not what you will become. Whose you are.”


The disciple looked toward the icon of Christ.


“His.”


“Yes.”


“I know that.”


“No. You are beginning to know it.”


The words stung, but gently.


“For years,” the elder continued, “you knew yourself through things that were holy. Priesthood. Ministry. Community. Teaching. Monastic longing. Service. Even your usefulness to others.”


“Those are not bad things.”


“I said they were holy.”


“Then what was wrong?”


“Nothing. Until you needed them to tell you who you were.”


The disciple was silent.


“And now,” the elder said, “God has not necessarily taken them all away. He has simply made them incapable of carrying the weight of your identity.”


“Why?”


“So that Christ can carry it.”


⸻


The disciple rubbed his face.


“Father, I am tired of discernment.”


“Then stop discerning.”


He laughed.


“Can I do that?”


“For tonight.”


“And tomorrow?”


“Tomorrow you may discern whether to have tea.”


The disciple laughed again.


The elder smiled.


“You have spent years asking where you will live, where you will belong, what will become of your priesthood, whether you are a monk, whether you will be received, whether you will ever have a canonical place again.”


“Yes.”


“And tonight?”


“I will go home and care for my mother.”


“Yes.”


“I will say my prayers.”


“Yes.”


“I will answer messages from people who are hurting.”


“Yes.”


“I will probably read Saint Isaac.”


“Almost certainly.”


“And tomorrow?”


“You will get up and do it again.”


The disciple sighed.


“That does not sound very dramatic.”


“God is curing you of drama.”


⸻


Evening had begun to gather around the cell.


The disciple said:


“I used to imagine that finding my place would feel like a great arrival.”


“And now?”


“Now I think I would simply like to stop explaining myself.”


The elder looked at him.


“Yes.”


“To enter the church without carrying my whole history through the door.”


“Yes.”


“Not to be the Catholic priest interested in Orthodoxy. Not the priest on leave. Not the man with the complicated canonical history. Not the monk who may or may not ever reach his monastery. Not someone whose future has to be discussed before anyone knows what to do with him.”


“What then?”


The disciple’s voice became very quiet.


“A Christian.”


The elder smiled.


“A rather ambitious goal.”


The disciple laughed.


“Perhaps just a sinner, then.”


“Better.”


“A sinner standing with other sinners before Christ.”


“Better still.”


⸻


The disciple looked at the lamp burning before the icon.


“I think that is what I want, Father.”


“What?”


“To walk into the church.


To cross myself.


To venerate the icons.


To stand where there is room.


To hear the psalms begin.


To smell the incense.


To pray words that do not feel borrowed.


To hear the Name of Jesus spoken with the same love with which I have learned to speak it in solitude.


And not to wonder, even for that hour, whether I belong there.”


The elder said nothing.


“I do not need anyone to make something of me.”


The elder continued listening.


“I do not need to stand at the altar.”


Silence.


“I do not need anyone to call me Father.”


Still the elder said nothing.


“I think I would be content simply to stand in the back.”


Then the elder spoke.


“Now we are getting somewhere.”


The disciple smiled.


“By going to the back?”


“Usually.”


⸻


After a while the disciple said:


“But there is grief in that.”


“Of course.”


“I have been a priest most of my adult life.”


“I know.”


“I love the priesthood.”


“I know.”


“To say that I could stand in the back and ask for nothing does not mean that what came before means nothing.”


“No.”


“It feels sometimes as though I am burying a man who is still alive.”


The elder’s expression softened.


“Then do not bury him.”


“What should I do?”


“Give him to Christ.”


“Is there a difference?”


“A great one. We bury the dead. We offer the living.”


The disciple’s eyes filled with tears.


“And what will Christ do with him?”


“That is none of your business.”


The disciple laughed through the tears.


“You are merciless, Father.”


“No. I am trying to leave room for mercy.”


⸻


They remained silent for a long time.


Finally the disciple said:


“Perhaps that is what I have been unable to do.”


“What?”


“Leave room.”


“For what?”


“For God to give me a life I did not design.”


The elder nodded.


“I wanted to know whether I would be a priest, a monk, both, neither. Whether I would belong here or there. Whether the years behind me would be carried forward or simply end.”


“And now?”


“Now I want Christ.”


“Good.”


“And I still want a home.”


“Good.”


The disciple looked surprised.


“You are not going to tell me to renounce that?”


“No.”


“Why not?”


“Because you are not asking for a throne.”


The elder leaned toward him.


“You are asking for somewhere to kneel.”


⸻


When it was time to leave, the disciple stood.


At the door he turned.


“Father.”


“Yes?”


“Do you think there will ever be a day when all of this becomes simple?”


The elder thought for a moment.


“No.”


The disciple laughed.


“That was not the answer I wanted.”


“You asked whether life would become simple. I said no.”


“Then what am I hoping for?”


“That you will.”


The disciple became still.


The elder continued:


“Perhaps one day God will give you an ecclesial home. Perhaps there will be a place where you no longer feel yourself standing between worlds. Perhaps you will enter the temple and realize that no explanation is required.”


The disciple listened.


“And when that day comes, do not immediately ask what your role will be.”


“What should I do?”


“Stand there.”


“And then?”


“Pray.”


“And then?”


“Receive what is given.”


“And then?”


“Go home.”


The disciple smiled.


“That is all?”


The elder looked at him with great tenderness.


“My son, after so much wandering, do you not understand?”


He pointed toward the door.


“There would be an enormous mercy in the word


simply.”

2 Comments


ljfrasier
Nov 06

Words seem too shallow to convey enough appreciation for these glimpses of the depths of your heart. The heart of another is such holy ground. This is beautifully written sharing of what it means for you to be where you are and where you would like to be. My heart yearns for you to find all that you seek. Perhaps it’s God‘s mercy for those of us that are here on this site and in your discussions that keeps you where you are. You have certainly been an answer to prayer for me. I felt like a stranger among my companions because I wanted more than what others seem to be satisfied with. Not more than Christ, but more of…

Like
Father Charbel Abernethy
Nov 06
Replying to

Dear Linda,

Thank you for your beautiful and generous words. They mean more to me than you know. There is a vulnerability in sharing something of one’s inner life, and I am grateful for the tenderness and understanding with which you have received it.

I was especially moved by what you said about wanting not more than Christ, but more of Christ. I think that longing is something many of us carry, often without knowing how to express it or where to turn. It can leave us feeling strangely alone, even among those with whom we share our faith.

It brings me great joy to know that the writings of the Fathers and our conversations have helped you find something…

Like
bottom of page