top of page

When the World Becomes a Place of Fear

Father Charbel Abernethy
Nov 12
9 min read

On wounded trust, the courage to be vulnerable, and the healing of the heart in the presence of God



“Perhaps the deepest healing begins when we discover that we no longer have to be strong enough to face the world alone.”


⸻


There are wounds that enter a human life before the mind possesses the language to understand them. They become part of the way we encounter the world, shaping our expectations of others, our understanding of ourselves, and even our capacity to recognize love. We may carry them for decades without knowing precisely what has been wounded. We simply discover that certain things are difficult: trust, vulnerability, dependence, the surrender of control. What others experience as ordinary encounters with life may awaken in us an anxiety that seems disproportionate to the circumstances. Yet the fear is real, and its origins may lie far beyond our conscious memory.


I have come to understand something of this through my own history.


As a child, I suffered a serious accident, falling from a height and fracturing my skull. I remained in a semi-comatose state for a period of time. Although I eventually recovered physically, I have no direct memory of the event itself. Yet I have long recognized that something fundamental changed in my experience of the world. Reality became a place of uncertainty and potential danger. My confidence in myself, my abilities, and my capacity to respond to life’s demands was deeply affected.


The accident also changed the atmosphere within the family. Those most closely connected to what happened carried their own fear and anxiety. I do not speak of this to assign blame. Love itself can become entangled with fear when those we cherish have been threatened or nearly lost. A family may continue to love deeply while struggling to recover the freedom and confidence that once characterized its relationships.


In such circumstances, anxiety can become almost a shared language, communicated without words and absorbed without understanding.


As I grew older, I developed a particular way of responding to fear. Rather than seeking to understand it or communicate what I was experiencing, I would force myself into the very situations that awakened it. What psychology describes as a counterphobic response became a familiar pattern. I moved toward what frightened me, sometimes with considerable determination, as though endurance itself could establish the safety and confidence I lacked.


There was genuine courage in some of this. I would not dismiss it. Yet courage can become entangled with an almost desperate need to prove that fear will not prevail. A person may learn to function remarkably well under difficult circumstances while remaining inwardly overwhelmed. The capacity to endure can conceal a profound inability to rest.


I recognize now that this pattern continued well into adulthood, including my years of priestly and religious ministry. The demands of vocation, obedience, responsibility, and service provided many occasions for generosity and genuine self-giving. Yet they could also become settings in which I repeatedly confronted anxiety through an exertion of will that left little room for understanding or tenderness toward my own vulnerability.


This does not render those years false. The grace received was real, as were the love and desire for God that drew me forward. But the human heart is rarely moved by a single desire. Our most sincere offerings can be accompanied by fears we have never learned to name.


The Fathers understood this complexity with remarkable depth.


Their vision of the human person was never limited to outward behavior. They sought to understand the movements of the heart, the hidden attachments of the will, and the ways in which the passions alter our perception of reality. For Evagrius and the tradition that followed him, the struggle with thoughts was inseparable from the purification of the heart. We do not simply respond to the world as it is. We respond to the world as it appears through the memories, fears, desires, and judgments that have taken shape within us.


A wounded person may therefore encounter danger where another perceives uncertainty, rejection where another intends no harm, or abandonment in the silence of someone who remains genuinely loving.


These experiences cannot always be corrected through explanation. The heart may understand intellectually that it is safe while the body continues to respond as though danger were imminent. Such wounds require patience, understanding, and often the assistance of others who can help us recognize what we have never been able to express.


Yet there is another dimension to this struggle, one that reaches into the deepest mystery of our existence.


We are created in the image and likeness of God. Our life is fundamentally relational, ordered toward communion with Him and with one another. From the beginning, our humanity unfolds through encounters with others. We learn to recognize ourselves through relationships that gradually reveal both our distinctness and our belonging.


When those encounters are marked by fear, neglect, trauma, or overwhelming uncertainty, our capacity to receive the other may become compromised. Even the symbolic world through which we understand love, authority, intimacy, and dependence can be affected.


This has profound consequences for the spiritual life.


The images we carry of God may be shaped by experiences that have little to do with His actual nature. The person who has known abandonment may find divine hiddenness almost unbearable. One who has lived beneath the weight of judgment may struggle to believe in mercy. Another, whose survival has depended upon constant vigilance and self-reliance, may find surrender to Providence deeply threatening.


We may speak of trusting God while remaining inwardly governed by the conviction that everything depends upon us.


Here the teaching of St. Isaac the Syrian becomes especially precious. His understanding of the spiritual life is rooted in the inexhaustible mercy of God and in the gradual softening of the heart before that mercy. He recognizes the weakness and fragility of human nature without reducing the person to those weaknesses. The ascetical struggle is always ordered toward love, toward the recovery of a heart capable of receiving God and embracing the whole of creation with compassion.


The healing of the passions, therefore, involves more than the correction of disordered behavior. It concerns the restoration of our capacity to perceive reality truthfully and to respond to it in freedom.


Modern psychology can offer indispensable assistance in this work. It can help us understand trauma, recognize patterns of anxiety, and discover how experiences long buried continue to shape our relationships and choices. Psychological healing and spiritual healing should never be placed in unnecessary opposition. The human person cannot be divided into separate compartments, as though the wounds of the mind and body were irrelevant to the life of the soul.


Yet the Christian understanding of healing also opens upon a mystery beyond psychological integration. We are not simply seeking to become more secure within ourselves. We are called to a communion that exceeds the boundaries of the self altogether.


This is where the teaching of the modern elders has become increasingly important to me.


Their emphasis upon humility, simplicity, stillness, and the remembrance of God reveals a way of life in which the person gradually relinquishes the need to establish an identity through achievement or self-mastery. The hidden life becomes a place where the heart is freed from the exhausting labor of continually proving itself.


Such freedom is not easily received.


Indeed, the dismantling of the religious ego may be particularly painful when that identity has served, in part, as a defense against fear. What appears to be spiritual strength may sometimes conceal an inability to acknowledge weakness. The desire to be faithful can become entangled with the conviction that one must never falter, never disappoint, never admit uncertainty.


And because these patterns often develop over many years, they may become inseparable from our understanding of who we are.


I have written frequently about the stripping away of the religious self. I am beginning to see more clearly how deeply this process reaches into the earliest experiences of life. What must be relinquished is not necessarily something wicked or deliberately false. It may be a way of surviving that once seemed indispensable.


There is grief in recognizing this.


One may look back upon decades of sincere effort and discover how often love was accompanied by fear, how frequently obedience was burdened by anxiety, and how difficult it was simply to receive the goodness of God without feeling compelled to respond through some extraordinary effort.


Yet such recognition need not lead to despair or the repudiation of the past. Grace was present even within these struggles. God was not waiting for us to become psychologically whole before drawing near. His mercy was already at work within the very life we were struggling to understand.


Perhaps this is one reason the Jesus Prayer has become so central to my experience.


“Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on me, a sinner.”


There is an extraordinary simplicity here. The prayer gathers the whole person before Christ without requiring that everything first be understood or resolved. We come with our history, our anxieties, our failures, and our longing. We bring even those parts of ourselves that remain frightened by intimacy and uncertain of love.


The Name becomes a place of encounter.


In the repetition of the prayer, there is no demand to manufacture an experience or achieve a particular spiritual state. We return because we need mercy. We remain because there is nowhere else that the heart can find its true home.


Slowly, the grammar of the heart begins to change.


Trust becomes less a matter of confidence in our own ability to manage life and more a willingness to remain open to the presence of God within it. We discover that vulnerability need not be overcome before communion becomes possible. Indeed, the acknowledgment of our vulnerability may be what finally allows us to receive the love we have spent so many years seeking.


I find this particularly poignant in the hidden circumstances of my present life.


The ordinary demands of caregiving, the limitations imposed by age and illness, the uncertainty surrounding the future, and the gradual relinquishment of familiar forms of ministry have brought me into contact with dimensions of myself that years of activity could sometimes obscure. There is little opportunity to construct an impressive spiritual identity within the daily rhythms of caring for another person. The demands are immediate, repetitive, and often exhausting. They reveal our impatience, our limitations, and our inability to control the course of events.


Yet they also reveal the possibility of love without self-assertion.


I am learning that the deepest ascetical labor may sometimes consist in remaining present without attempting to master what is unfolding. To care without possessing. To act without demanding certainty. To acknowledge fear without allowing it to govern every choice.


And perhaps, above all, to allow God to be God.


For the living God is not an image fashioned from our need for security. He is not the projection of our wounds or the fulfillment of our demand that reality become manageable. He is the One who reveals Himself in Jesus Christ, whose love enters the full vulnerability of our humanity and opens it to communion with the Father.


The encounter with Him does not erase our history. Nor does it necessarily remove the psychological consequences of experiences that have shaped us since childhood. But it can transform our relationship to that history. What once seemed to determine the boundaries of our existence may gradually become something we can acknowledge, grieve, and entrust to His mercy.


There is no need to force this process toward a premature resolution.


Some wounds require a lifetime of patient attention. Some fears remain even as our capacity to love deepens. The saints themselves knew weakness, sorrow, and the painful experience of their own limitations. Their holiness did not consist in becoming invulnerable but in allowing the whole of their humanity to be drawn into the life of God.


I think now of the child who fell, who awoke to a world that seemed less secure than before, and who would spend so many years trying to find the courage to move through it.


I would not tell that child that he needed to become stronger.


I would want him to know that he was loved, that his fear could be spoken, and that he did not have to bear it alone.


Perhaps the spiritual life brings us, after many years and many unnecessary struggles, to the threshold of this same discovery.


We are not asked to conquer reality in order to live within it. We are invited to receive our existence as a gift, even in its fragility, and to discover that the One who called us into being has never ceased to sustain us.


The healing of the heart is a long and often hidden work. It unfolds through grace, through the kindness of others, through the painful recognition of our wounds, and through the ordinary acts of trust that gradually become possible.


And sometimes, after a lifetime of forcing ourselves through fear, the most difficult and beautiful act of courage is simply to remain still before God and allow ourselves to be loved.

1 Comment


bob.kasarda
Nov 13

My anxiety, searching for control and perfection, and shame in failure thank you for this, as does the current me.

Like
bottom of page