top of page

The Violence of an Unguarded Heart

Father Charbel Abernethy
Nov 10
5 min read

On the Hidden Tyranny of Self-Will and the Terrible Responsibility of Having Received Mercy



Gospel: Luke 12:42–48


“Blessed is that servant whom his master when he comes will find so doing.” — Luke 12:43


⸻


There is a violence that never raises its hand against another. It takes place in the hidden chambers of the heart, where a man gradually ceases to live before God and begins to live for himself. He may continue to pray, to fast, to teach, even to speak eloquently of divine things. Yet something has shifted. The Lord is no longer the center around which his life turns. His own will has quietly taken the throne.


This is the terrible warning of the Gospel.


The unfaithful servant does not begin by beating his fellow servants. He begins with a thought: “My master is delayed in coming.”


The Fathers would have us linger here, for the whole tragedy is contained in this single movement of the mind.


The servant begins to live as though God were absent.


He does not deny his master. He simply ceases to expect him.


And when the living awareness of God disappears from the heart, self-will rushes in to occupy the emptiness.


This is how the soul becomes tyrannical.


We ordinarily imagine tyranny as something exercised over others. Yet the desert fathers understood that its roots lie within us. The man who cannot bear to have his will contradicted has already become a tyrant. The one who must justify himself, defend his importance, secure his position, or bend circumstances to his desires has begun to beat his fellow servants, even if his blows are delivered only through impatience, resentment, judgment, or the withdrawal of love.


How easily religious life itself becomes the instrument of this violence.


We may use obedience to demand submission from others while refusing to surrender our own will. We may speak of truth without tenderness, of asceticism without humility, of fidelity without love. We may even use the language of holiness to conceal our fear of becoming nothing.


The Fathers were merciless toward such deception because they understood how merciful God is.


They knew that the most dangerous passions are often those that have learned to clothe themselves in virtue.


A man may renounce possessions and remain fiercely attached to his reputation. He may abandon the world and carry its entire kingdom within his heart. He may seek solitude not because he loves God but because he cannot endure being contradicted. He may pursue spiritual perfection because he is terrified of being loved in his poverty.


The outward life may appear ordered while the inward life remains enslaved.


And Christ sees.


He sees not merely what we do but what moves us to do it.


The faithful steward, by contrast, is almost painfully ordinary. He gives the household its food at the proper time. He does not seek to possess what has been entrusted to him. He does not make himself the center of the household. He does not confuse responsibility with dominion.


He simply remains faithful.


There is something profoundly humbling here. The Lord does not praise the servant for extraordinary visions, heroic achievements, or the construction of some great spiritual work.


He praises him for being found doing what love requires.


Perhaps this is one of the hardest truths for the religious heart to accept.


We would rather accomplish something great for God than allow Him to strip us of our need to be great.


We would rather imagine a magnificent obedience somewhere beyond the horizon than embrace the small and often humiliating obedience that stands before us today.


To feed those entrusted to us. To bear another’s weakness without resentment. To endure interruption without anger. To pray when prayer offers no consolation. To remain gentle when exhausted. To surrender the need to know what tomorrow will bring.


These things expose the heart more completely than many heroic undertakings.


For here there is little room for spiritual vanity.


Here love must become real.


The desert fathers understood that watchfulness is not anxious anticipation of punishment. It is the refusal to allow the heart to become forgetful of God.


The master comes at an unexpected hour because the servant was never meant to live apart from his presence.


The question is not merely whether we shall be ready at death. It is whether we are living before God now.


Is Christ present to us in the person who needs our patience? In the weakness that frustrates our plans? In the poverty that strips us of certainty? In the circumstances that refuse to conform to the life we imagined for ourselves?


Or have we begun to say, perhaps without words, “My master is delayed”?


I will love when my life is settled.


I will pray when my mind is quiet.


I will be gentle when others cease to burden me.


I will surrender when I know what God intends.


But the Lord comes precisely in what we wish to postpone.


And we do not recognize Him.


The final words of the Gospel are especially severe: “Every one to whom much is given, of him will much be required.”


We often hear this as a demand for greater achievement. Yet perhaps its most searching meaning lies elsewhere.


The more deeply we have encountered mercy, the less excuse we have for withholding it.


The more we have tasted forgiveness, the more terrible our refusal to forgive.


The more we have received the knowledge of Christ, the more grievous it becomes to use that knowledge in the service of pride.


Spiritual knowledge is not a possession. It is a responsibility that exposes us to judgment.


Indeed, the man who knows the language of the spiritual life may be in greater danger than the one who knows nothing of it. He can describe humility without becoming humble. He can analyze the passions while remaining their servant. He can speak of surrender while secretly arranging everything according to his own will.


He can become an expert in the things of God while remaining a stranger to God Himself.


This is a fearful possibility.


And it should silence us.


For the Gospel is not given so that we might identify the unfaithful servant in another. It is given so that we might discover him within ourselves.


There is no room here for self-congratulation. No room for imagining that years of prayer, ministry, sacrifice, or suffering have made us immune to deception.


Perhaps the deepest asceticism is to allow the Lord to reveal how little we have truly surrendered.


To see our impatience without defending it.


To acknowledge our pride without disguising it as zeal.


To recognize our fear without calling it prudence.


To confess that even our longing for holiness may have become entangled with the desire to possess ourselves.


And yet this exposure is itself a mercy.


Christ does not reveal the falsehood of the heart in order to destroy the person. He reveals it so that what is false may die and what is true may finally live.


The faithful servant is not the man who has achieved mastery over himself.


He is the man who has ceased trying to be his own master.


He belongs to Another.


And so perhaps the most faithful response to this Gospel is neither fear of the future nor renewed determination to become extraordinary.


It is to return to the Lord in the poverty of this present moment.


To cease striking others with the violence of our expectations.


To cease demanding that life justify itself before our desires.


To cease postponing love until we feel secure.


To stand before Christ without pretense.


And to ask for the grace to be found, when He comes, doing the one thing entrusted to us:


Loving those He has placed before us, with the mercy we ourselves have received.


Nothing more.


Nothing less.


For the Master has never been absent.


It is we who have wandered from His presence.


And even now, He stands at the door of the heart.

1 Comment


bob.kasarda
Nov 10

“The more deeply we have encountered mercy, the less excuse we have for withholding it.”

Gulp

Like
bottom of page