top of page

The Courage to Remain at the Threshold

Father Charbel Abernethy
2 hours ago
11 min read

St. Sophrony and the purification of longing through patience, uncertainty, and prayer



“I waited patiently for the Lord; and he inclined unto me, and heard my cry.”

— Psalm 39:2 (Septuagint; Psalm 40:1 in most English Bibles)


The Heart at the Threshold — Reflection VII


There is a kind of waiting that becomes increasingly difficult precisely because the heart has grown more certain of what it desires. We often imagine that uncertainty is most painful when we do not know which direction to take, when the possibilities before us remain confused or our desires are divided. Yet there is another form of suffering that emerges when something within us has become clear, when a longing has taken root so deeply that we can no longer pretend it is passing, and still we find ourselves unable to move toward its fulfillment.


We stand before something we have come to love, yet cannot enter it by the strength of our desire.


The heart begins to experience time differently. Days that once passed almost unnoticed become occasions for expectation. We wonder whether something has changed, whether a conversation has taken place, whether a decision is drawing nearer. We tell ourselves that we are willing to wait, and perhaps we sincerely are. Yet beneath that willingness there may remain a restless desire to know what others are thinking, to understand what is happening beyond our sight, or simply to receive some assurance that our longing has not been forgotten.


There is a particular vulnerability in having placed something precious into the hands of another and then discovering that we can do little more.


I have come to know something of this vulnerability. After many years in which the direction of my life seemed largely established, I find myself standing before questions I cannot resolve through effort, experience, or careful reflection. I have lived long enough to recognize the limitations of my own judgment, and perhaps long enough to be more suspicious of the certainty with which I once approached important decisions. Yet this knowledge does not always make waiting easier.


There are moments when I feel a deep peace about what has become clear within my heart. There are other moments when that same clarity seems to intensify the difficulty of remaining still. I find myself wanting to explain more, to make certain that I have been understood, to remove whatever uncertainties might remain in the minds of others. I can begin to imagine conversations that have not taken place, difficulties that have not been raised, and obstacles that may exist only in my own anticipation.


What begins as a desire for understanding can quietly become an attempt to manage what lies beyond my control.


The Desert Fathers were unsparing in their recognition of such movements. They understood that self-will does not always appear as open rebellion or the refusal of obedience. Sometimes it appears in our insistence upon knowing, in the need to secure reassurance, or in the subtle conviction that if we could only explain ourselves more completely, the path before us would become clear.


We may even begin to regard our anxiety as evidence of the importance of what we desire.


Yet the sincerity of a longing does not free it from the need for purification.


This is one of the more difficult lessons of the spiritual life. We can desire something good, something deeply consonant with the Gospel, and still discover within that desire an attachment to our own understanding of how and when it should be fulfilled. We may be willing to relinquish many things, yet remain unwilling to relinquish the timetable. We may surrender the outcome in words while continuing to rehearse, inwardly, the means by which we hope to bring it about.


And when nothing happens, we suffer not only from the delay itself but from the gradual exposure of our inability to control it.


St. Sophrony’s correspondence with David Balfour offers a particularly searching witness to the necessity of spiritual discernment at such moments. Throughout their exchanges, the question is never merely whether a particular desire is sincere or whether an outward decision can be justified. The deeper concern is the state of the heart before God. How easily can spiritual aspiration become entangled with self-confidence? How readily can our longing for God become confused with our longing for a particular experience of God, or with the desire to see our lives unfold according to a pattern we have come to regard as necessary?


St. Sophrony does not permit the spiritual life to be reduced to the strength of our convictions. He directs us toward repentance, humility, and the difficult knowledge of our own poverty.


This is especially important when we believe that we have finally recognized something for which we have been searching for many years.


Recognition can bring peace, but it does not make us incapable of error. A profound spiritual attraction does not dispense us from discernment. Nor does the conviction that we have been led by God give us the right to interpret every delay as an obstacle placed before His will.


We must remain willing to discover that even our most cherished desires contain something that needs to die.


Yet this does not mean that we must extinguish desire itself.


The Christian life is not a gradual descent into indifference. The saints did not become holy because they ceased to long for God. Their longing became more intense, more consuming, and at the same time more free from the need to possess what they loved.


St. Silouan knew the suffering of a soul that longs for God and experiences His apparent absence. His writings reveal a love that does not become less ardent through humility. Rather, humility protects love from becoming a claim upon God. The soul cries out for Him, but gradually learns that it cannot command His presence, determine the measure of His grace, or make its own experience the measure of divine providence.


This is a difficult freedom.


It asks us to remain open, vulnerable, and desirous without turning our longing into a demand.


I have often thought that waiting would become easier if only I knew what was being asked of me. If there were a clear path, however difficult, I could begin to walk it. If there were a sacrifice to make, I could at least consider how to offer it. If there were an obstacle to address, I could seek counsel and respond.


But there are times when no such clarity is given.


We are left with the responsibilities already before us, the prayer we can offer today, and the uncertainty that accompanies us into the following morning.


It is here that I have begun to see how much of my spiritual life has been shaped by the impulse to act. For many years, I understood fidelity largely through availability, service, and the willingness to respond to whatever was asked of me. There was much good in this, and I remain grateful for it. Yet activity can also become a refuge from the poverty of waiting. We may prefer even a difficult task to the vulnerability of being unable to do anything that will hasten the fulfillment of our desire.


There is something within us that would rather struggle than remain empty-handed.


And perhaps this is why waiting can reveal attachments that years of labor and sacrifice have left untouched.


St. Isaac the Syrian repeatedly returns us to the necessity of patience, humility, and the knowledge of our weakness. For Isaac, the spiritual life is not measured simply by the intensity of our ascetic efforts but by the transformation of the heart through repentance and divine mercy. We must learn to endure the disclosure of our poverty without fleeing into self-justification or despair.


This endurance is not resignation.


There is a patience that arises from fear, from the unwillingness to speak, or from the belief that we have no right to seek what is good. Such silence can become another form of bondage. The Fathers do not ask us to abandon discernment, conscience, or truthful speech. There are moments when love requires us to ask a question, to clarify our intentions, or to speak plainly about what we can and cannot undertake.


But there is also a time to recognize that we have spoken sufficiently.


That we have placed the truth before another as honestly as we know how.


That further explanation may no longer serve understanding, but only our own desire to be relieved of uncertainty.


This distinction is not always easy to make.


I know how readily I can persuade myself that one more conversation, one more clarification, or one more carefully chosen word might bring peace. Sometimes such communication is necessary. At other times, I recognize that I am seeking something no human response can finally provide: the assurance that I will not be disappointed, misunderstood, or asked to endure a future different from the one I hope for.


No one can give us such assurance.


And perhaps no one should.


For the spiritual life would become terribly small if its peace depended upon our ability to foresee what lies ahead.


There is another difficulty in waiting that I have come to recognize more clearly. The longing of the heart does not remove the claims of the present moment. Life continues around us. People still need our attention. Responsibilities do not become less real because our thoughts are drawn toward an uncertain future.


Indeed, the very intensity of our longing can make these ordinary demands seem like interruptions.


We may find ourselves physically present while inwardly living somewhere else, anticipating a conversation, imagining a decision, or rehearsing a future that has not yet been given to us.


And so the heart becomes divided, not necessarily between good and evil, but between the good it desires and the good that is immediately entrusted to it.


I have had to confront this division within myself.


There are days when I recognize that my attention has wandered far beyond the circumstances in which God has placed me. I am thinking about what may happen rather than attending to the person before me. I am seeking a future obedience while becoming impatient with the obedience of the present. I am longing for stillness while allowing uncertainty to rob me of the silence that is already possible.


This recognition is humbling.


It reminds me that I cannot postpone the Christian life until the circumstances of my life have been resolved.


I cannot wait to become prayerful until I know what tomorrow will bring.


I cannot reserve my peace for the moment when others have understood me.


And I cannot claim to desire communion with Christ while allowing my longing for its fuller realization to diminish the love I owe those who are already near.


The threshold is not a place outside the spiritual life.


It is one of the places where the spiritual life becomes most exacting.


Here the Jesus Prayer takes on a particular simplicity. There are moments when I have no desire to analyze my circumstances further, when reflection itself has become exhausting and the mind can find no new path through the uncertainty. I can only return to the Name of Jesus.


Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on me, a sinner.


The prayer does not resolve what remains unresolved. It does not tell me what others are thinking or when the future will become clear. It does not guarantee that my hopes will be fulfilled in the manner I desire.


But it returns me to the One whom I am in danger of losing sight of through my preoccupation with His gifts.


It places me again within mercy.


And sometimes that is enough for the moment.


I am beginning to understand that the courage required at the threshold is not the courage to force open a door. Nor is it the courage to pretend that the door no longer matters.


It is the courage to remain before it with an undivided heart.


To acknowledge the depth of our longing without making it the measure of God’s faithfulness.


To speak when truth requires speech, and to remain silent when further words would only serve our anxiety.


To receive counsel without surrendering conscience.


To accept delay without imagining that every delay is holy, or that every obstacle must therefore be God’s will.


And above all, to remain faithful to the love immediately before us while entrusting what lies beyond our reach to the mercy of Christ.


I do not write these things as one who has mastered them. Quite the contrary. I write because I continue to discover how difficult they are, and how much within me still resists the poverty they require.


There are moments when I would gladly exchange the uncertainty of waiting for almost any difficult task. I would rather be asked to undertake something demanding than remain without knowing what is being asked of me. Yet I am slowly learning that my inability to act does not mean that nothing is happening within the heart.


Something is being revealed.


The desire to be understood. The fear of being forgotten. The need to know that the sacrifices of the past have not been meaningless. The wish to protect myself from disappointment. Even the longing to give myself wholly to God can become entangled with the need to know what that gift will look like.


These things do not disappear simply because we recognize them.


We must bring them repeatedly into the light of Christ.


And perhaps this is where the heart begins to grow larger. Not because its longing has diminished, but because it is learning to carry that longing without allowing it to consume everything else. It begins to make room for the freedom of others, for the limitations of human understanding, for the responsibilities of the present, and for a providence it cannot yet comprehend.


The heart becomes capable of waiting without withdrawing its love.


I find myself returning to this again and again.


I do not want uncertainty to make me suspicious of others. I do not want longing to become resentment, or patience to become a carefully concealed accusation against those whose decisions I await. I do not want to measure the sincerity of another’s care by the speed with which he responds to me.


And I do not want the intensity of my desire to become an excuse for neglecting the quiet demands of love that fill my days.


There is a freedom in being able to say that I have spoken truthfully, offered what I can, and need not continually defend the sincerity of my heart.


What remains is not indifference.


It is trust.


Not the certainty that everything will unfold as I hope, but the willingness to remain before Christ even if it does not.


Perhaps this is the deepest poverty of the threshold: to love something enough to wait for it, while refusing to make its fulfillment a condition of our peace.


I do not know what shape the coming years will take. I cannot say that I am without fear, nor that I have ceased to imagine what might lie ahead. There are longings within me that have only grown stronger with time, and I would be dishonest if I pretended that their fulfillment mattered little.


They matter deeply.


But I am beginning to see that I need not make them smaller in order to entrust them to God.


I can desire with my whole heart and still leave room for His judgment, for the discernment of others, and for the possibility that I have more to learn.


I can remain at the threshold without turning away from what I love.


And while I wait, I can pray, repent, care for those entrusted to me, and seek to become more truthful before God.


Perhaps that is enough for today.


Not because the longing has been satisfied, but because Christ has not ceased to be present within it.


And if tomorrow finds me standing in the same place, with the same questions and the same unfinished hopes, I pray that I may have the courage to begin again.


Not by demanding an answer.


Not by withdrawing my heart.


But by turning once more toward the Lord and saying, as simply as I can:


I am here.


You know what I desire.


Teach me to remain in Your love.


Prayer


Lord Jesus Christ, You know the longings I carry and the fears that accompany them. You know how readily I seek reassurance, how quickly uncertainty gives rise to restless thoughts, and how easily I begin to imagine that everything depends upon my ability to act. Have mercy on me. Purify my desires without extinguishing them. Give me the courage to speak truthfully when I must, the humility to remain silent when I have spoken enough, and the patience to wait without bitterness. Do not allow my longing for what lies ahead to diminish my love for those You have entrusted to me today. Keep my heart open, my conscience clear, and my prayer simple. Whether the path before me becomes clear or remains hidden, teach me to abide in You. Amen.


Spiritual references: St. Sophrony of Essex, Striving for Knowledge of God: Correspondence with David Balfour, particularly his spiritual counsel concerning discernment, humility, and self-will; St. Silouan the Athonite, teachings on humility, longing for God, and the experience of grace; St. Isaac the Syrian, Ascetical Homilies, on patience, the knowledge of one’s weakness, and perseverance in prayer; the Desert Fathers, particularly their teachings concerning self-will, watchfulness, and the restraint of unnecessary speech.

Comments


bottom of page