A Dialogue on the Burning Heart
- Father Charbel Abernethy
- Nov 11
- 3 min read
In the dim cell of a mountain hermit, a single oil lamp flickers. The night has been long, filled with psalms and tears. St. Isaac sits near the wall, weakened from illness but watchful. His disciple, a young monk trembling from what he has seen, kneels nearby, unable to find words.
⸻
Disciple: Father, my heart trembles at what my eyes have witnessed. That brother, how can flesh endure such fire? He struck the ground again and again as though his bones were not his own, as though he were all flame and breath. I pitied him, yet I envied him too. Tell me, is this what love does to a man?
Isaac: You have seen love when it takes hold of a soul and drives it beyond measure. You have seen what the world calls madness and what God calls sanity. Do not be quick to imitate it, my son, but do not despise it either. Grace has her own measure, and she gives according to the strength of each heart.
Disciple: I do not despise it, Father, but I am crushed by it. I thought myself zealous, and now I see that I know nothing. My prayers are cold, my fasts are vanity, my tears are shallow. I saw in him something that was not of this world. His body was broken, his face pale as wax, but his soul, his soul blazed. What kind of man can live like that?
Isaac: No man can, unless another dwells within him. The Spirit of God turns weakness into a furnace. Do you not see, my son, how grace transfigures frailty? The body becomes a reed, the breath a sigh, the will consumed. He no longer acts by his own strength, but by the strength of the One who moves all things. That is why such a man weeps and strikes the earth, not from compulsion, but because love overflows and must find its form.
Disciple: Yet it frightens me. I saw him cry out with joy and then fall as if dead. I felt shame for him, as though he had lost reason. And yet I wept too. Father, what happens to a man when God draws so near?
Isaac: When divine fire touches the heart, reason bends like iron in the forge. The mind cannot contain what the heart receives. Do not think it strange that joy breaks him. Such cries are not of madness but of love unendurable. It is as if his soul stands at the edge of eternity and cannot step back.
Disciple: Then why do you pity him, Father? You said his body was wasting away, that his zeal might destroy him.
Isaac: Because love, when unguarded, can consume its vessel too soon. Grace gives wings, but the clay cannot always bear flight. I pity him as one pities a candle burning too bright; it illumines all around, yet hastens its own extinction. Still, who can rebuke the flame for its brightness? God Himself will measure his offering.
Disciple: And what of me, Father? I feel like ash beside him. I rose to pray, and my thoughts wandered before the first psalm was done. Is there any hope for one whose love is so small?
Isaac: There is no other path, my son, than to mourn your coldness before the face of God. Do not despise the ache you feel; it is the first mercy. The heart must break before it can burn. That brother has wept for years in secret. You have only now begun to see your poverty. Blessed are you if this sight wounds you deeply, for from that wound will come the longing that never sleeps.
Disciple: Then my shame is not in vain?
Isaac: No, it is the door. Keep it open. Let humility be your prayer, and tears your bread. God will see your hunger and feed you with the crumbs of His fire. Do not seek the ecstasy of the saints; seek their repentance. For repentance itself is the beginning of the kingdom.
Disciple: Father, I think I begin to see. The kingdom is not distant; it burns here, in this cell, in the weary bones of the one who prays.
Isaac: Yes, my son. The kingdom is not far off. It begins when a man forgets the world and remembers God alone. It begins when he falls to the earth and whispers, “Have mercy.” What you saw tonight was not madness but fulfillment, the heart that has already crossed the threshold, though the body still kneels upon the dust.
⸻
The lamp sputters. The disciple lowers his head and weeps, not from despair, but from a strange sweetness that pierces him. Isaac sits in silence, the shadow of the cross falling across his face. Outside, the wind carries the sound of the brethren chanting the psalms, and the desert listens.
_edited.jpg)



This dialogue emerged through reflecting upon St. Isaac's description of an elder in Homily 21 paragraphs 1-6.