Charism, fracture, and the call to repentance in wounded spiritual communities

“Where there is no repentance, there is no life.”

— St Sophrony of Essex

⸻

Forgiveness Sunday

As the Church approaches Great Lent, she places on our lips the words Forgive me.

This is not a polite exchange. It is a spiritual crossing.

We cannot step into the fast while carrying our enemies with us.

We cannot ask God for healing while refusing it to one another.

Forgiveness Sunday does not erase wounds, but it opens the only door through which they can be healed.

It asks us to stand not as judges or survivors but as sinners in need of mercy.

What follows is written in that spirit.

Not to assign blame, but to tell the truth that repentance alone can redeem.

⸻

There are ways a religious community can decline that are far more dangerous than open scandal or doctrinal error. The most destructive erosion is almost always invisible. It happens quietly under the cover of good intentions, respectable language, and institutional survival.

The fathers of the desert were clear about this. St Isaac the Syrian teaches that the gravest sins are not always those that appear scandalous but those that replace repentance with self-justification and love with calculation. A community can continue to function, even to grow, while its soul is slowly being hollowed out.

Most religious communities are born from a charism that is intensely personal. A founder suffers, prays, is wounded, and gives birth to a way of life not from theory but from fire. For a time that fire warms everyone. But when the founder dies or withdraws, something delicate is exposed. Unless elders arise who have themselves passed through the same crucible, the charism remains as words, structures, and memory, but no longer as living transmission.

At that point the community faces a choice. It can become smaller, poorer, and more hidden while preserving its heart, or it can preserve its size, property, and influence by slowly substituting management for spiritual fatherhood. Many choose the second path without realizing it.

The desert fathers warned about this very pattern. When elders disappear, they said, monasteries become places of order without wisdom. Discipline replaces discernment. Rules replace relationship. The outward form remains, but the inward fire grows cold.

This shift is often reinforced by generational and psychological forces. Newer members arrive with different expectations of authority, security, and identity. They bring real gifts, but also new fears. The culture outside the monastery does not stop at the cloister gate. Anxiety about money, aging, healthcare, and relevance begins to shape decisions that are no longer guided primarily by ascetic truth but by institutional survival.

When that happens, material things begin to carry spiritual weight. Buildings, endowments, and reputation quietly become sacred. Financial stability replaces poverty. Efficiency replaces patience. Risk is treated as irresponsibility. Yet the Gospel was never safe, and neither was the desert.

St Sophrony warned that when monastic life loses its eschatological tension, it collapses into something merely moral and administrative. People are no longer formed for eternity, but managed for functionality. Members become roles rather than persons. They are valued for what they do rather than who they are becoming before God.

This is one of the deepest wounds a community can inflict on its own. A monk or religious who is seen primarily as a function rather than as a beloved son or daughter will either harden, wither, or quietly break. The fathers knew this. They insisted that obedience without love becomes tyranny and that structure without mercy becomes a tomb.

Psychological dynamics then begin to dominate. Unhealed leaders project their fears onto the community. Older members cling to control as their inner vitality fades. Younger members internalize anxiety as zeal. Silence becomes dangerous. Honest grief becomes disloyalty. The atmosphere grows brittle.

Perhaps most tragic of all is the loss of repentance. Not repentance in words, but repentance as climate. In a healthy community, everyone is allowed to be weak. Tears are welcome. Forgiveness is quick. There is generosity of spirit even when people fail. But when a community becomes defensive, repentance is replaced by image management. The appearance of holiness becomes more important than the truth of brokenness.

St Isaac says that God dwells where there is humility and gentleness. He does not dwell where there is self-protection disguised as righteousness.

In such an environment, those who still live from the heart of the charism begin to feel like strangers in their own home. They are not rebelling. They are grieving. They sense that something holy is being lost even while everything looks fine. They are often the ones who carry the memory of the fire, and so they become inconvenient.

Many leave not because they have lost faith, but because they have refused to lose it.

Yet no one who has lived inside such a story can speak of it as an innocent observer. We are never only the wounded. We are also, at times, those who wound. The same forces that deform a community also pass through individual hearts. Fear, self-protection, pride, exhaustion, and the hunger to be seen quietly distort even sincere seeking.

It is easy to diagnose sickness in structures, leadership, and culture. It is far more painful to recognize how deeply the same sickness can take root in oneself. The fathers teach that the truest knowledge is not insight into others, but the discovery of one’s own poverty. Without that, even accurate analysis becomes another form of self-justification.

There are moments when we fail to become healers not because we do not know the truth, but because we do not have the courage to suffer with it. We turn away from weakness, both in ourselves and in others, because it frightens us. We protect ourselves rather than standing in the place of affliction where Christ alone heals.

And so the losses can be real. Lives can be pushed aside. Trust can be broken. Good intentions can still leave deep wounds.

Yet the Gospel is not finally about diagnosis. It is about mercy.

God does not abandon individuals or communities in their disorder. He does not wait for us to become healthy before drawing near. He enters the very place of confusion, sin, and fracture. He becomes the Divine Physician precisely where the disease is deepest.

The modern elders teach that true repentance does not collapse the heart inward, but enlarges it. Elder Sophrony wrote that when a man stands before God in sincere humility, the boundaries of his heart are broken open and he begins to carry all mankind within himself. What once felt like betrayal or threat is slowly transfigured into sorrow for the whole world. The more we repent, the less we are able to hate. The more we see our own poverty, the more we begin to desire not our own vindication, but the salvation of all.

In the bow of Forgiveness Sunday, the wounded Church begins again by entrusting herself not to justice, but to the mercy that alone makes us one.